I Fell For You // Jacob Sartorius FanFic {Completed}

I Love You...

One Week Later

     It's the next weekend on a Saturday and Chloe and I have more plans with Brandon and Hunter. Yeah, yeah you're probably thinking "you like Hunter don't you". Well me and him are just friends, and I hate when people assume that just because I'm talking to a guy when I have a boyfriend it means I like him. We are just friends! If Jacob was here I would be spending time with him, not Hunter, but he is on tour so I am hanging out with Hunter.
     Anyways, today we are going to a movie theater to see Get Out. It's a horror movie but I don't know what it's about. I guess I'll find out...

     Hunter and Brandon walked over to our house to pick up me and Chloe. We walked back to their house so their mom could drive us to the theater. Once we got in the theater we got out tickets and our popcorn. The four of us finally entered the room for Get Out and me and Hunter sat in the very back and Brandon and Chloe sat in two seats right in front of us.
     About 20 minutes into the movie it started getting really scary. There were so many jump scares! At some parts of the movie where it was kinda boring Hunter and I kept throwing popcorn at each other! It was so fun.
     Towards the end of the movie there was a really scary part and I could not watch it! So I put my head on Hunter's shoulder and closed my eyes. He grabbed my hand and for some reason I let him do it. He knows that I am dating Jacob...

     After the movie all of us decided to walk home. The theater is only like 2 miles from our houses so we thought it would be nice to take a stroll.
"That movie was so scary!" Chloe exclaimed as we walked out of the building.
"You're telling me," I signed.
"It wasn't that bad," Hunter said.
"Not that bad? Even I got scared!" Brandon admitted.
"Guys..." I mumbled, "where's my phone?!"
"You probably left it in the theater!" Hunter told me.
"Dang it!" I shouted.
"I'll go back with you to find it," Hunter said.
"Chloe and I will walk home," Brandon said smiling at Chloe.
"Yeah," Chloe agreed.
"Fine let's go Hunter," I said stomping towards the theater again.

We walked back to the theater and told the people working in the front that I left my phone in here. They let us search the room we were in and I found it on the ground under the seat I sat in. Thank god I found it or my mom would have killed me! Once we found it we headed home again.
"Tonight was really fun!" Hunter said as we approached my front door.
"Yeah it really was!" I replied.
"I'm glad you had fun," Hunter said as he stared into my eyes.
"I did," I told him as I looked back into his.
We both leaned in and shared a small kiss. Right as I knew what I was doing I pulled away.
"Hunter I-" I said.
"Sierra I know you like me," Hunter interrupted.
"But I'm dating Jacob, and I love Jacob," I whispered.
"Then why did you just kiss me?" Hunter asked.
"I- I don't know. I can't do this. Im sorry Hunter," I said opening my front door.
"It's okay," Hunter said as he turned around and walked back to his house.
I walked up to my room, shut my door and though "What did I just do? Why did I just kiss Hunter?!".

I couldn't stop thinking about the kiss. I tried falling asleep but I just couldn't. Who did I really like? Jacob or Hunter? Who is the real boy of my dreams?
I grabbed my phone from my nightstand and went to my contacts. I pressed on the contact of the boy I really wanted. I typed "I love you" into the text box and pressed send. I sent those three words to...