Elsa x Fem Reader One shots (Requests Closed)

27. Cheater

Requested: Elsa cheats on reader but is not forgiven. 

I made my way around two people making out and stepped outside. The party was getting crazy, and I wanted to find Elsa so we could go home, watch a movie and cuddle. 

She said she was going to get some non alcoholic drink, but that was 10 minutes ago and I don't know where she is now. I'm getting a little worried, and even though she promised she wouldn't drink, I hoped she wasn't passed out drunk somewhere. Plenty of bad things happen at parties when people are intoxicated. 

"Looking for your girlfriend?" A pretty brunette came up to me. I think her name was Honeymaren; we had a few classes together.

"Yes," I said, looking over her shoulder at the people outside. 

She bit her lip, "I saw her go upstairs with someone else a little over five minutes ago." 

"What? She wouldn't," I said, more to myself than Honeymaren. I rushed past her and into the house, running up the stairs.

I opened the door to a closed room and saw a cheerleader and a football player in bed. They seemed more annoyed than embarrassed that they were caught.  

"Just looking for the bathroom," I muttered before closing the door. I didn't want to walk in on any more couples sleeping together, and I didn't know what room to enter. 

I suddenly heard moans, and though I've never slept with Elsa, it sounded just like her. I slowly opened the door, and what I saw shocked me. A girl was on top of my girlfriend, unbuttoning her shirt. I saw purple marks on Elsa's neck, and strands of her braid were loose. I looked for any signs that Elsa was drunk, but the way she was moving and mumbling to hurry up was clear that she was sober. 

"Y/N!" Elsa exclaimed, finally noticing me. The girl on top of Elsa covered her mouth with her hands, looking between me and Elsa. 

"Y/N, I-" I slammed the door in disgust and hurt, and quickly walked out of the house. 

"Hey, Y/N," Honeymaren came up to me, but by the expression on my face she could probably tell what just happened, "I'm sorry."

"It's okay," I mumbled. 

"Y/N," I heard Elsa shout behind me, and I excused myself from Honeymaren and continued to walk away. I felt a hand on my shoulder and immediately turned around and took it off. 

"I'm sorry," Elsa said, tears streaming down her face.

"What am I not enough for you? You need to go screw someone else to satisfy you?"

"No, no that's not it! I just-" 

"How long?" I asked, cutting off her protests.

She hesitated, "Three months."

"That's about the time when I told you I didn't want to do it," I scoffed, "Well I'm sorry our movie dates sucked, I'm sorry I took you out to get coffee every Tuesday, sorry that you hate dancing with me, sorry that I can't cuddle right, sorry that I can't satisfy you!" The majority of the people were looking at us, but most of them were drunk. 

"You're a good girlfriend, Y/N, I'm sorry, I-"

"Well I wasn't good enough, was I? We're over Elsa," I said, turning away. She let me walk away, and Honeymaren put her hand on my shoulder. 

"Do you need a ride home?" she asked softly. 

"I think I need to walk and have some time with my thoughts. Thanks though." 

*******

It's been about two months since my breakup with Elsa, and I've just started a relationship with Honeymaren. I knew she liked me for a couple years, and I had started to hang out with her more, and eventually fell for her. 

She's honestly the best, appreciating all the little things I do for her, and surprising me with dates and gifts as well, something Elsa didn't really do. She taught me how to cook and how to fish, and I taught her how to play soccer and to paint.

Elsa kept trying to talk to me, but I just brushed her off or walked away. Whatever she wanted to say I didn't want to hear it. But I couldn't escape when she cornered me after school. 

"Please, can we just talk," she begged. I glanced over at Honeymaren who was waiting for me by my car. 

"You okay Y/N?" she asked, ready to interfere if I wanted her to. 

"I'll be with you in a minute," I said. I turned back towards Elsa.

"I'm sorry for cheating on you, I really am. I broke it up with Crystal, and I haven't dated anyone since. I have no excuse for doing it, and you were right, I wanted something  you weren't ready to do, and that was wrong and unfair of me. You're the best thing that's ever happened to me, and I realize that I was a horrible girlfriend and I didn't deserve you. I'm so sorry, Y/N." 

I knew she really was sorry, but I couldn't go back to her, "I know you are, and thank you for your apology.  I'm in a happy relationship now, and I can't go back to you when you did that. I really loved you, Elsa, and I'm sorry things had to end this way."

I walked towards Honeymaren who looked relieved, when I heard her voice, "Can we be friends?"

"Maybe in time." 

I reached Honeymaren and she smiled after I gave her a quick kiss. 

"I'm driving, I have a surprise for you," she winked.

I handed over my keys with a grin, "To wherever you want to take me."