Ask/Dare The Creepypastas

Dare To Any Creepypasta

Masky: Alright, now that that traumatizing scene from Jeff and Toby, not you Sally; is over, we can go on to the next dare.

Ticci-Toby: If it was you Tim, it would be an abomination.

Masky: *slamming the camera in frustration* Toby!

BEN: Just get on with the dare already!

Masky: FINE! NovatheFox0001 dares one of us to make Jeff a cake..

Jeff: Alright, more servitude! Someone, get to it!

Eyeless Jack: Could you quit bossing us around? More than half of us are older than you anyways...

Jeff: *smirking* Doesn't matter to me, you all still do what I say.

Neliotis: Well you're a bit intimidating...

Jeff: Alright yeah yeah, someone just get to making my cake already.

Nina: I'll do it!!!!!! *she speeds off to the kitchen.*

Jeff: ....someone seriously go with her and make sure she doesn't put any poison in there...

BEN: Or in your case, she'd put 'love' poison~

Jeff: SOMEONE GO!

Clockwork: *sighing* I'll help her, I don't wanna see Jeff suddenly head-over-heels for that chick anyways...

*She gets up and goes to the kitchen. Not long after, they hear arguing.*

Slenderman: Oh brother. -_-

~timeskip~

*Nina skips out of the kitchen, holding a plate with big cake in her hands, and a wide smile on her face. Clockwork slowly follows, a tired and pissed look on her face.*

Nina: Oh Jefffff~! You're special cake is ready, I did it all for you!

Clockwork: I helped to--

*Nina quickly slaps her hand over Clockwork's mouth and hands the cake to Jeff.*

Jeff: *looking at it uncertainly* Thanks....I

Nina: Well? Eat it and tell me how you like it~!

*Jeff looks at the purple and black cake with a bunch of heart-shaped frosting and candies spread around it. On top was written, "Love, from Nina."*

BEN: *looking at the cake* You forgot to add "Love from BEN" too, lol

*Nina smacks BEN and turns back to Jeff.*

Jeff: ....Maybe I'll try it later.

Nina: *quickly grabbing ahold of Jeff's wrists* Eat it now....

Jeff: Get your hands the fuck off me and chill...

*He sighs and takes out his bloody knife, using it to cut the cake.*

Darkside & Neliotis: Ew...

*Jeff eats some of the cake* ....

*Nina smirks and hums "Cake" by Melanie Martinez.*

Jeff: Um....I guess it's alright...

Nina: Isn't it? Look me in the eyes and say so~

Jeff: *grumbling and looking up at her* I said it's alr—

*Jeff's voice trails off as he stares at Nina and Nina's smirk widens.*

Smile Dog: Jeff...?

Jeff: *beginning to smile sheepishly* Wow Nina, your cake is amazing....just like you....

Everyone: ???????????????

Nina: Oh Jeff, how sweet!

Clockwork: What the—Nina!? What did you do to the cake??

BEN: I thought you watched her make it?? Way to go, Clock-wimp!

Clockwork: I DID WATCH HER! She may have added in something when my back was turned...

Nina: Nonsense, I made the cake just as the instructions said.

Masky: She's a liar.

*Jeff jumps up and takes Nina's hands.*

Jeff: You really are something, huh Nina~?

Nina: So are you, my prince~.

Useless Jack: This is disgusting.

Jane: This is hilarious.

BEN: Slender?? Can't you do something about this??

Slenderman: I'm not intervening in your shit. You'd better find a way to fix this.

BEN: ME???? IT WAS CLOCKWORK AND FRIGGIN' NINA!

Trenderman: *laughing nervously* She may have stolen a forbidden item from my room and used it in the cake...heh heh....but don't worry, I have the reverse potion, I just have to find it...

Slenderman: Well hurry up. They're starting to cuddle and it's making me sick..

*Trenderman nods and quickly runs to his room to get the reverse potion thingy.*