Erwin Smith x Reader One Shots

💔 🔥 Real Life 2 🔥 💔

Written: January 27, 2021

Takes place: A little after Eren joins the Scouts

Request: Requested by a lot of people.

Note: I kinda like this chapter...

~~~

"Do you know the future?"

"I do."

"Tell us!" Hanji said excitedly.

"How can we be sure that what you say is true?" Erwin said full of doubt.

"I can tell you something private about your past that no one else here would know." Erwin nodded.

"Very well." You tried to remember some of their secrets.

"Erwin, you believe you are the reason your father is dead." His eyes widened ever so slightly. "You told his theory to the other kids and then the Military Police killed him. Ever since then you've been trying to prove his theory right." Hanji and Mike looked at Erwin in surprise. "You also don't care about humanity. It's just been on the same path as your dream-"

"That's enough. Hanji, Mike, leave us."

"But-"

"Out." Once they left, Erwin stood staring at you for awhile. Finally, he sat down. "How do you know how my father died? Are you from the military police?"

"No. I already told you-"

"I don't believe you."

"After what I've told you? You still don't believe me?"

"You could've found out about my father from the MPs. As for the rest it could all just be guessing. Or maybe you've analyzed my behavior."

"I'm not from the military police. I know what I'm telling you is hard to believe, but I know the future, I know things about you no one else does. It's because you all are really a story in books. I know what happens in those books which is why I know everything-"

"Then tell me, are there people outside the walls?"

"I-... I don't think I should tell you."

"Because you don't know."

"I do know! But I don't think I should tell you because I could mess up time and the whole plot!"

"Now I know you're lying. You said you came here because you wanted to meet me. Because you were in love with me, but if that were true, you'd be telling me the truth. You'd know how much proving my father's theory means to me." He was clearly trying to guilt trip you into telling him, but you fell for it.

"No, stop. Please, I do love you. I just- I just-"

"Then tell me." Tears built up in your eyes and you shook your head.

"I shouldn't... I can't do it. I might disturb the whole course of time here." As if a new person, Erwin got down on his knees and held your hands lightly. He even put one of his hands on the side of your face. Your heart raced, and everything felt like it was on fire.

In the calmest voice possible, he said, "Listen to me. You know how much I want to know-" You looked away from him, but he tilted your face back towards him. "Just tell me. You know, there's a good chance that I'd fall in love with the angel who told me such a revelation." Tears were streaming down your face now. You wanted to give in so badly. Maybe if you told him he wouldn't try to go to Eren's basement. Maybe he wouldn't die.

"I can't. I can't." Erwin's face went dark.

"What do you want from me? What is it?" He was clearly getting desperate. "I'll do anything Y/n. Just tell me. I'll do whatever you want. I'll-I'll marry you-... I'll have sex with you." Your face turned pale and your tears suddenly stopped. Erwin smiled at your hesitation. "That's what you want isn't it?"

"N-no. No." His hand traveled up to your hip and he leaned in closer to you. You pushed him away halfheartedly, but you knew you couldn't resist the temptation. His lips met yours and you closed your eyes. Your whole body was quivering with anticipation. So many times had you dreamed about this; being with Erwin, and now it was happening.

So you let it happen. It was unlike anything you had experienced before, but like all good things, it had to come to an end. When it was over, Erwin whispered into your ear, "Now tell me." Your heartbeat accelerated. You never agreed to tell him, but how were you supposed to say that to him after what you'd done?

"I-I'm sorry Erwin. I can't." His face steeled. He put on his pants and shirt. He opened the door where Hanji was standing with her ear to the door.

"Get Levi and take her to the basement." Hanji nodded and left.

"What?" You said confused while dressing. "What's in the basement?" Erwin went over to his desk and took something out. He watched you put on your clothes and then he came over to you. Something cold wrapped around your right hand and then you heard a click and it wrapped around your left hand. That was when you realized he handcuffed you.