First Forever (GirlxGirl)

Mistaken Identity

Anna's POV

Eva and I walked back out and she jumped straight into the pool, making a big splash. I laughed then ran to the pool house to get the water guns and filled them up. I came back and threw one each for Cooper and Katie, they were the best shooters. The others scrambled out the pool screaming and we ran after them.

Cooper, Katie and I showed no mercy. After realizing that even though we were few in numbers, they were no match for us, they surrendered. Although it was a complete ambush and they were destined to lose from the beginning, we celebrated still.

"Y'all little fuckers ambushed us!" Jessica shouted out of breath.

"Oooo y'all gotta be quicker than that." said Katie and laughed.

"Yeah cause one of you assholes sprayed me in my eye." Eva complained and held her left eye. I walked over to her and removed her hand from her eye. It was red and slightly swolled.

"Damn, that does not look good. Come, I have eye drops in my bathroom." I said and led her inside. We got upstairs, into my bathroom and she sat on the edge of the bathtub. I looked through the cabinet and found the eye drops in no time.

"Okay, it says two drops should do." I said. I dropped the prescribed amount and waited for her to let it sink in.

"Boon, have you noticed Jessica's body?" she asked.

"Uhmm, is this a trick question?" I responded, very confused.

"Where's your phone?" she asked.

"Probably downstairs, why?" I questioned.

"Listen I have this theory that maybe Jessica is behind the nudes." she said.

"What nud-ohhhh. Oh my gosh, baby! No! Do you have proof?" I asked as I sat next to her on the tub.

"Well the person's body looks just like hers and I only noticed when I saw her in the bathing suit today. Plus she has two phones and she went into that shady tech store in the mall. I mean it all makes sense, right?" she explained.

"Baby, listen to me. If you accuse her without evidence, you could create a wound that may never heal." I warned.

"So what do I do?" she asked.

"Well just leave it alone. It's not a problem to me." I said nonchalantly.

"Yes it is Boon! Why are you so calm about this? Wait! Do you enjoy the pictures?" she asked.

"Eva, don't do this. I'm just saying you should proceed with caution, okay. And no I don't enjoy the nudes. Why would I when I have you." I said and pulled her on my lap to face me, legs on either side. I invaded her space with kisses on her neck that made her giggle. Then I slowed down and kissed her lips while she massaged her fingers in my hair.

The dainty kiss we started with then graduated to a sultry exchange of tongues. Our breathing got heavier and I began to untie her bathing suit string. I stood up not breaking our kiss or letting go of her, she just wrapped her legs around my waist.

I walked us out the bathroom and sat on the bed. She gripped my hair and pulled my head back and began to lick and suck my neck. Her tongue and lips on my neck feel so satisfying that I let out an involuntary moan.

Eva's POV

Anna moaned which riled me up more and I began to grind on her. Suddenly her door swung open "Bitch! Where the fuck is my phone"?

I looked up and saw Jessica standing in the doorway with her arms folded. Anna sighed and looked at me then back to Jessica.

"Yo you can't barge in here like that!" she said.

"Eva. Give. Me. My. Phone!" Jessica shouted and slowly advanced towards us. I got off Anna's lap and stood up.

"I know you're the one sending Anna the nudes, you're a fucking weirdo!" I shouted. Jessica stopped in her tracks and looked at me with a pain I've never seen in her eyes. I immediately realized I was completely wrong.

"Eva, are you for real? You're joking, right? You think I'd do that to you?" she said and tears filled her eyes. I walked over to her but as I got close she slapped me and was about to slap me again until Anna intervened, picked me up and stepped back with me.

"Woah! Woah! What the fuck is happening? Eva do you have her FUCKING phone???" Anna shouted as she put me down.

"Yes." I answered softly. Anna looked at me for long time then shook her head.

"Give it to her." she commanded. I went to the closet and retrieved the phone from under a pile of hoodies and gave it to Anna who then gave it to Jessica.

"Don't you dare speak to me again." Jessica angrily said and left. I stood there in shock at how quickly that escalated all because of my poor judgment and I began to cry. Anna wrapped her arms around me instantly and comforted me.

"I fucked up big time. I fucked up big time." I repeated. Anna didn't say anything she just swayed us back and forth and rubbed my back. I cried my heart out as I replayed the situation, how it could've been avoided and how I accused my sister of something so vile, why would I? Anna just hugged me and never let go until I pulled away.

"I don't want to go home tonight. I really fucked up Boon, I really did." I cried.

"Shhh, listen. You are more than welcomed to stay with me bub. It's now a little after five so I'd have to drop the girls home soon. Let's take a shower and then do that, okay?" she said and I agreed. We both showered separately and Eva slipped on my black Nike sweatsuit and I wore Nike shorts and a hoodie with a pair of AF1's. She went downstairs and I followed soon after.

"Ayo, what happened? Your sister left an hour ago with tears in her eyes." Katie said.

"Well I kinda accused her of sending Anna nudes." I answered.

"Yoooo Anna you getting bitches?" Katie said and snickered. Anna simply scoffed.

"Eva, you accused her of the ultimate betrayal between sisters. She's probably so hurt." Sab said. I felt the tears form and I tried to hold it back. I looked at Anna and she once again embraced me in her comforting arms.

"You girls get ready, I'll drop you home." she said and the girls left. She swayed us back and forth and intermittently kissed my head. She walked us out to the jeep and stood infront of me while I sat in the driver's seat and hugged her waist tightly. She just rubbed my back in silence.

I felt stupid for even thinking my sister would do something like that. I had to mend what I broke before it was too late.

The girls finlly came out and Anna said "Beautiful, time to leave." and pulled me up, gave me one more hug and wiped my tears. We all got in and Anna turned to me and pushed back piece of my hair to see my eye. She got out and jogged back in the house to get the eye drops I presumed.

"I swear she handles you with so much care. She wasn't even talking to you earlier and she still fixed your plate." Katie announced.

"Yeah she is very gentle until she isn't." I said and winked at Katie. Dev and Sab covered their mouths and screamed. Katie sat up in the middle and looked at me.

"Bruh I'm not even surprised." Katie said and we burst out in laughter. That was a necessary laughter but it didn't take my mind off of the damage I had done earlier.

Anna came back and met the jeep filled with laughter. She didn't question anything she just smiled and drove out.