That Butler, Isekaid (Modern!Reader Insert)

That Butler; Kindsfhurer

"Allow me to introduce, Louise of Houndsworth, Nora of Wolphinhel, and... Jutte. The true culprit of all the crimes thus far..."

Ciel's eyes widen in shock as the true identity of the culprit is revealed. Louise, Nora, and Jutte—all the same person, responsible for the crimes that have plagued Houndsworth and Wolphinhel. The realization sends a surge of anger and betrayal through him, his voice laced with a mix of fury and disbelief. "Nora... You are Louise and Jutte as well?" Ciel asks, his voice filled with a mixture of disbelief and slight fascination. "You orchestrated all of this—creating a divide between Houndsworth and Wolphinhel, inciting hatred, and perpetuating the cycle of violence between both communities. But why? What could drive you to commit such acts?"

Sebastian's lips curl into a malicious smile as he addresses Louise, his voice dripping with sadistic satisfaction. "You certainly went to great lengths to exact your revenge, Miss. Masquerading as Nora and Louise, you sowed discord between the humans and the werewolves. And as Jutte, you orchestrated the killings to frame _________ and instigate fear."

"No way- why?? How??" Gustav exclaims in confusion and fear...

_______ steps forward, their voice firm and resolute. "Your daughter was replaced with an imposter, get with it blud"

Jutte's eyes gleam with a mix of anger and anguish as she speaks, her voice filled with sorrow. "It was my vengeance...my punishment to them. The pack abandoned my mother, left her for dead. And then the villagers burned us and treated us like the monsters we never were! I wanted them to feel the same pain and loss I felt. I wanted them to suffer as I did."

Ciel's expression softens, his voice gentle yet firm. "Jutte, your pain and anger are understandable, but taking innocent lives will not bring you the solace you seek. It will only perpetuate a never-ending cycle of pain and revenge. Let us help you find a different path, find a way to heal your wounded heart."

"This started but a year and a half ago, when Louise went missing. When 'Louise' was lost, there were far too many open loops, the chimney where the 'wolf' could've come from wasn't all soot, the window was only ever small enough for one body to come out and there was little to no blood. Also, one girl, and one wolf were not accounted for. Only leaving one logical explanation, Louise and the werewolf switched places. Jutte- or the imposter Louise planned and staged her own kidnapping. With the accounts of the villagers, Jutte and Louise resembled each other so much- to a fault."

______ steps forward, as Jutte half-heartedly glares down at them, "The bites for the lost girls were not the same as the bites for the 'bad dogs', making it clear that Alma was only responsible for the 'bad dog' incidents. And yet you used her as the culprit to your almost perfect crime. Finding Alma's corpse in your tunnel just days after her rampage and after we fell from the waterfall. Evidently enough, even girls of the werewolf village were being killed as well. And last night- 'Nora' had been killed. Though you thought you could put that blame on me. But the real murder happened in the underground tunnel you'd been hiding in. You dipped Louise into the lake, put clothes on her shot her dead and carried her out. No human would be able to do it, as the moths in the cave would've sullied their clothes. Only a being that can get through without the need for light could do it. There were even signs of one living in that cave tunnel."

"On the wall of the cave, were eighteen months' worth of tally marks designated "probation" but those carvings barely reached Sebastian's thighs and were just about C's height if he sat. The cave was quite large, there were obvious signs of someone living there, but could not walk. Someone who couldn't stand, who disappeared a year and a half ago... There's only one person-" ________ continues, Gustav muttering his daughter's name.

"Exactly. By the time we came, she was no longer there. Louise and Nora were about the same age. If Nora had been killed in the underground Louise was in, then perhaps the one that was killed was not Nora, but Louise. Here comes the full picture- Jutte who was able to escape death through the tunnel in the old clock tower of Houndsworth where she and her mother were supposedly burnt to death- Changed her name to Nora and lived in the werewolf village. Later taking Louise's place and kept going back and forth between the villages- playing both roles. It was very possible, with these 5 reasons."

_____ crosses their arms over their chest, eyes clashing with Jutte's. "The two villages never interacted with each other aside from their belief of the Demon Hound's powers at play. Second, the underground passage connected the two villages in a much shorter- less time consuming route. If traveled at a werewolf's pace, would likely take just an hour. Third, both villages were active at different times of the day. Houndsworth in the morn and Wolphinhel in the eve. Fourth, Louise who lived her life mostly isolated- and Nora who also lived in solitude. Fifth, the lake in the underground cave. Werewolves have an acute sense of smell, but if they bathed in the lake to rid themselves of their scent, the others would be none the wiser."

The (hair color) then walks over to Ciel, looking into his eyes. "Then, when the Earl and Sebastian returned and Louise's corpse was found. The injury was the same as the one that Nora had. The corpse had been reused, Nora dug up the corpse, and made it look as if she had been attacked by a wolf"

"I didn't eat her or anything however, I just bit her... I'm not that heartless." Jutte refutes, glaring at the people and werewolves below. "Sorry sorry. I mean nothing by that. However- you still tampered with the corpse and brought it to Houndsworth."

"Vera helped dig up the sight of Nora's coffin, but her body was not there. So- all of it comes to one truth. The culprit of the Houndsworth losses, is the imposter Louise, and the Wolphinhel's culprit for their losses, is Nora. All in all, executed by the same individual- Jutte..."

Ciel listens attentively to _____'s deductions, his mind piecing together the puzzle that has plagued Houndsworth and Wolphinhel for so long. His eyes meet Jutte's, a mix of disappointment and understanding reflected in his gaze. Ciel's eyes widen as he slowly pieces together the puzzle in his mind. The revelation is chilling, the web of deceit spun by Jutte intricately woven.

"So, Louise...or should I say Jutte, you played both sides, manipulating the villagers of Houndsworth and Wolphinhel, orchestrating events that led to countless deaths and despair. All to exact your revenge for the abandonment and mistreatment you and your mother suffered..." Ciel's voice takes on a tone of eerie calmness. "Your plan was elaborate, to say the least. Switching places with the real Louise, living a double life, and setting the stage for the blindness and ignorance of both villages. No one suspected that you were behind it all. It took a series of events and a keen eye to finally unravel your deceit."

Sebastian, standing beside Ciel, smirks darkly. "Impressive, I must say. Your ability to masquerade as two individuals and deceive everyone around you is truly remarkable. But, as skilled as you are, your actions cannot be justified. The lives that were lost, the pain and suffering you caused cannot simply be brushed aside."

Sebastian steps forward, a hint of curiosity in his eyes. "The question now is, what do you plan to do with this newfound knowledge, and how will you make up for the lives you have taken?"

Gustav's voice trembles as he looks at Jutte with a mix of sorrow and anger. "You...you took my Louise away from me. You monster...!"

"Hmph."