Five Hargreeves x Fem!reader
Warnings: none
Five had first met Y/n at a coffee shop near the academy. He was waiting for his siblings, silently sipping his black coffee, when she walked in. The air seemed to change when she smiled at the barista, her laughter filling the room like a melody. Five's heart skipped a beat.
He'd watched her from his corner table, feeling a strange pull toward her. When their eyes met, he felt an instant connection, a spark he hadn't experienced in his long, convoluted life. Despite the scars of time and the burdens he carried, Five felt a flicker of hope.
Y/n, oblivious to his inner turmoil, simply smiled back and went about her day.
Five's encounters with Y/n became more frequent as if fate were drawing them together. They would often chat in the coffee shop, sharing stories and laughing over the absurdities of their respective lives. For the first time in ages, Five found himself looking forward to something other than his Job.
Their friendship grew, becoming a beacon of light in his otherwise chaotic existence. Five cherished every moment with Y/n, savoring the way her eyes lit up when she talked about her passions, the way she laughed at his dry humor, and the comforting warmth of her presence.
But as their bond deepened, Five noticed a shadow looming over his happiness—a shadow in the form of Y/n's boyfriend, Michael.
Michael was everything Five wasn't—charming, kind, and stable. He treated Y/n with a tenderness and respect that Five could only admire from afar. The sight of them together, holding hands or sharing a private joke, was like a knife twisting in Five's chest.
Five kept his feelings hidden, burying his longing beneath a façade of stoic composure. He valued Y/n's happiness more than his own and refused to let his desires complicate her life. But the pain of unspoken love gnawed at him, especially when he saw the way Y/n looked at Michael, with a love that was pure and unwavering.
One rainy evening, as Five sat in the coffee shop alone, he saw Y/n and Michael walk in, laughing and soaked from the rain. They took a seat near him, not noticing his presence.
"I have something for you," Michael said, pulling out a small box. Y/n's eyes widened in surprise and delight as he revealed a delicate necklace, shimmering with a simple elegance.
"It's beautiful," Y/n whispered, her eyes brimming with emotion as Michael fastened it around her neck.
Five watched, his heart heavy with sorrow. He wished he could be the one making her eyes sparkle with joy, the one who could make her feel loved and cherished. But he wasn't. He was just a friend, an observer of the happiness he yearned to be part of.
Unable to bear the weight of his feelings any longer, Five decided to confide in Klaus, the only one who might understand his dilemma.
Sitting on the academy's rooftop, with the city lights twinkling below, Five finally opened up. "I love her, Klaus," he admitted, his voice barely a whisper. "But she's with someone else. And she's happy."
Klaus, for once, was silent, listening intently. "Why don't you tell her how you feel?"
Five shook his head, a bitter smile on his lips. "Because it wouldn't be fair to her. She deserves someone who can be there for her, someone who doesn't come with the baggage of a broken timeline and a fractured soul."
Klaus sighed, placing a comforting hand on his brother's shoulder. "Sometimes, the heart wants what it wants, Five. But you're doing the right thing, even if it hurts."
Five nodded, the weight of his unspoken love pressing down on him. He knew Klaus was right, but that didn't make it any easier.
The inevitable day came when Y/n and Michael announced their engagement. Five attended the celebration, putting on a brave face, congratulating them with a forced smile that didn't reach his eyes.
He watched from the sidelines as Y/n beamed with happiness, her eyes shining with a joy that made Five's heart ache. As the evening wore on, he found himself retreating to the quiet of the balcony, staring out at the stars, lost in his thoughts.
Y/n found him there, her expression concerned. "Hey, you okay?" she asked softly.
Five forced a smile. "Yeah, just needed some air. It's a big night for you."
Y/n stepped closer, her eyes searching his. "I'm glad you're here, Five. You mean a lot to me."
Her words, meant to comfort, only deepened the pain. "You mean a lot to me too, Y/n," he replied, his voice thick with emotion. "I hope you know that."
Y/n smiled, reaching out to squeeze his hand. "I do. Thank you."
Five nodded, unable to say more. As Y/n walked back inside, he took a deep breath, trying to steady himself. He knew he had to let her go, to accept that she would never be his. And despite the ache in his heart, he resolved to be happy for her, to cherish the moments they shared and to hold onto the memories of their friendship.
As the stars shimmered above, Five made a silent vow—to always be there for Y/n, even if it meant loving her from a distance. It was the least he could do for the woman who had brought light into his dark world, even if only for a brief moment.
Time moved on, and so did Five, carrying his unspoken love like a secret treasure. He continued his work, facing new challenges and navigating the complexities of his existence. But in the quiet moments, when the world was still and the weight of his responsibilities faded, he would think of Y/n and the love that could never be.
It was a bittersweet acceptance, a love that remained unspoken but forever cherished. And as Five looked up at the night sky, he found solace in knowing that some loves, though unfulfilled, could still bring a measure of peace to a restless heart.
YOU ARE READING
Number Five Imagines
Hayran KurguYou will dive deep into the life of Five Hargreeves, exploring scenarios where you are his partner in crime, confidante, and love interest. Each short Story offers a unique glimpse into different aspects of Five's multifaceted personality-his wit, h...