"You can kiss real good, love."
"R-really?"
"Yes."
"Well thanks I guess."
"No problem, love." We sat there for a while until she spoke again. "You want to kiss again, don't you?"
"Yes."
And with that we were kissing again. Does this mean we were dating? I mean we didn't have to be. We could be in a friends with benefits kind of situation, right? Shit. I need to breathe. I pulled back.
"Peggy?"
"Yeah."
"Will you be my girlfriend?"
"Yes!" That seemed desperate. "I mean yes!" Damnit!
"Great." She grabbed my hand and kissed my cheek. "Because I love you."
"I love you too."
Maria smiled.
I looked at her. "No one's signed you're cast." I smirked.
"Oh yeah, I know."
"Can I sign it?"
"Oh no. You don't have to."
"Do you have a Sharpie?"
"Here." She grabbed one off of my desk.
I signed my name in really big letters across her cast. "Now we can pretend we both have friends."
"And to show that I'm taken."
My heart melted. Sure John was sweet and loved Dear Evan Hansen, but he's now a gay bitch. He even put all over social media that he is gay. Fuck him.
"What should we do, love?"
"It's up to you."
"Alright then." She took out her phone. "Now did you say Heathers or Be More Chill?"
"I didn't. Heathers." So many references! I'm in heaven. Wait, am I? This is too good to be true!
"Great." She pressed play and we both laid down on my bed.
I held her hand. My phone buzzed. John. Ignore. He kept texting.
TurtleBoi🐢
Peggy I'm so sorry
I shouldn't have let that happen to you
I'm not even sure why I said it
Please answer
Please
Peggy
And Peggy 💛
Sorry for the whole slut thing or the "I'm totally gay" thing
TurtleBoi🐢
Both
And Peggy 💛
I already forgave you for the slut thing
TurtleBoi🐢
I want full forgiveness
I want to be friends
And Peggy 💛
Fine
Just explain
TurtleBoi🐢
My sexuality??
And Peggy 💛
Well everything. Even though I forgave you doesn't make us friends yet. I need to understand everything.
Maria let go of my hand and sat up. "Who are you texting, love? 'Our Love is God' is on!"
"John." I sighed.
"About?"
"He wants me to forgive him so we can be friends."
"Oh, alright."
"You aren't mad?"
"How could I be mad at you? Sure he did one wrong thing but you fixed it in hours!" She reached for my hand.
I smiled and continued texting him.
TurtleBoi🐢
I'll start from the beginning
When I first met you I thought you were a fucking brat but then again you were 3. I basically watched you grow up, but when we got to middle school Eliza and I stopped talking. In highschool we reconnected but still not as close. Then I saw you again when I was a freshman and I thought you were fucking beautiful. I knew there was no way I was full on homo. Then I met Alex. I thought he was pretty damn cute. So I guess I had a crush on both of you. Then there was the party where we started dating then Alex and Eliza stared dating. I know I told you I loved you and only you but that was a lie. I did love you but I loved Alex too. I was hanging out with him one day a few weeks into our relationship and I told him. Then we proceeded to make out and then went farther. He was my first not Lee. We continued to do it. That one party when you dressed like Maria, him and I had sex in the bathroom when everyone was sleeping. Eliza walked in on us because Lex couldn't wait a second to lock the door. She was upset until we explained to her and she was fine with it. We told everyone but you because we knew you'd get upset. Then that one night when you came over I realized that I was gay while we were having sex. I didn't want to tell you that it fidnt enjoy it because I couldn't stand to see you hurt. Then when I told the team it may have added more details about how you kind of wanted to do it for a long time. I don't know why I didn't tell you about it sooner or why I let them tell the story but it all happened.
And Peggy 💛
Well then gay boy
"Did you really lose your virginity to a gay guy?" Maria asked laughing.
"Shut up! Wait you aren't supposed to be looking at screens!"
"You let me turn on music."
"Leave me alone."
TurtleBoi🐢
Peggy I'm so sorry
And Peggy 💛
It's fine I get it
TurtleBoi🐢
You do?
And Peggy 💛
Of course
But one thing
TurtleBoi🐢
What?
And Peggy 💛
Well actually two
TurtleBoi🐢
Jesus Christ
And Peggy 💛
Number 1 are you still seeing Alex?
TurtleBoi🐢
Yes sometimes I go out with him and Eliza
I hope that's not weird
And Peggy 💛
How is that weird? Alex is bi AND poly that's not weird at all
TurtleBoi🐢
What's the second thing?
And Peggy 💛
Right
Number 2 Maria was reading this over my shoulder and said "Did you really lose your virginity to a gay guy?"
TurtleBoi🐢
Well you did
How is Maria?
Ang told us what happened
And Peggy 💛
Oh you mean my girlfriend? She's doing great
TurtleBoi🐢
You guys are dating! How cute?
Maria kissed my forehead. "I guess we're pretty cute."
I think I'm going to start writing my crossover book because why not.
YOU ARE READING
And Peggy
Fanfiction《COMPLETED》 (Modern Hamilton AU) Peggy was always overlooked. Her older sisters weren't. Nobody noticed her until she went to a few parties and became the Varsity cheer captian. John Laurens noticed her and someone else. Unfortunately, finally being...
