And Peggy

43

"Babes, do you want anything?" Maria asked wrapping her arms around my waist.

"No, but I'll come with you."

"So you're leaving us!" John pouted.

"Do you wanna come with us?"

John grabbed Alex's arm and pulled him into the kitchen.

"Jackie, what the hell?" Alex said rubbing his arm.

"Man up!" I said.

"Oh shut up!"

John got him, Alex, and Maria drinks. "You sure you don't want anything, Pegs?"

I sighed and held my hand out. "Just give me one."

He handed me a drink. I took a sip. Why did alcohol taste so bad yet so good? Eliza walked in to get another drink. She rolled her eyes at the sight of John. I wished her eyes would roll right out of her fucking head. "Hey, Eliza." I said.

She rolled her eyes again. "What?" She took a sip of her drink.

"Don't you want to hang out with us?"

She laughed. "Are you fucking kidding me? No! If you're gonna play a game, yeah, but otherwise, fuck off." She turned around to walk away.

"We'll play a game!" I shouted.

"We will?" John asked.

I elbowed him. "Yes, John, we will."

"What game?" Eliza asked.

"Truth or dare?" Alex suggested.

"Ew no." Eye Roll.

"7 minutes?" Maria suggested.

Eliza looked to Alex then me. "I'm in."

John and I gathered some people besides Alex, Maria, Eliza, and us. The only people who would play were Sally, Theo, Angie, Aaron, Laf, Herc Martha, Levi, and Thomas. We went up to John's room to be away from the other people.

"So how are we going to determine who goes with who?" John asked.

"What if everyone writes their name on paper and then we pick like that?" Alex said.

"That works." Maria said.

I wrote everyone's name down and put the pieces of paper in the middle of the circle. "Everyone, pick a name. If it's your name, we'll repick, got it?" Everyone grabbed a name. I got Alex. Wow. Someone who has had sex with my sister and ex. Nobody picked themselves suprisingly.

"Should we go youngest to oldest?" Angie asked.

"Why not? Sally, you're up." I said.

"Theo." She said.

"Oh, okay." Theo laughed. The two of them walked into the bathroom. They definitely didn't do anything because both of them were straight, but straight people are pretty weird.

"My turn." I said. "Alex."

"Really?" Alex laughed.

Eliza's jaw dropped as I shook my head. "I guess it's fair." She sighed as she rolled her eyes.

"Fair?" Alex asked looking to me.

"She kissed Maria when we were playing truth or dare with Cornelia."

"Oh." We walked into the bathroom and shut the door. "So are we going to do anything or what?"

"Well you're dating my sister who is out of her damn mind and my ex boyfriend who is also my gay best friend. What do you think?"

"Yes."

"You're a slut, Alexander Hamilton." I laughed.

"No shit."

"So you admit to it? I was only joking."

"But I am."

"How?"

"Just nevermind."

"No! Tell me the story!"

"I said forget it."

"Spillith thy tea!"

"I uh-" He leaned in and kissed me.

I pulled away. "What the fuck?" I just kissed my sister and ex's boyfriend. Holy shit.

"I'm sorry. I just can't tell you."

"Why? Don't you trust me?"

"No! I do. Believe me; I do. It's just-"

"It's just what?"

He sighed. "Fine. I kind of forced John to cheat on you."

"What?"

"I knew he liked me, but I wanted to prove it."

I just stared at him.

"You're mad now, aren't you?"

"No."

"Really?"

"Yeah. I mean it's nobody's fault John's gay as fuck."

Alex laughed. "Well we still have two minutes."

"We do?"

He shook his head. "Now what?"

"I don't know."

"We could kiss again." He said hesitantly.

"You're basically my brother." I shouted.

"Then that makes Maria and Eliza basically sisters, right?"

"Well yeah."

"So it shouldn't be an issue."

"You shouldn't want to kiss me."

"I wouldn't normally, but we're at a party playing 7 minutes."

I sighed. "Whatever, slut." He leaned in and kissed me. I gave into it this time. It felt so wrong kissing him, but it also felt good. Not in a sexual way; in a "my best friend who is kinda my brother is a slutty teenager" way.

I haven't updated in like forever and I'm sorry. I wrote this chapter in study hall while also texting my friend, so it's pretty trashy. I'll update more I promise! I'll try to get like 2 more tomorrow!!!