Supernatural Imagines

You What?! (Sam x Reader)

Warning- lots of smut

Summary: Y/N, Sam, and another girl at a party have a threesome. Y/N finds out something that makes her rage....

Sam and Y/N had been invited to a party by Dean. It was being hosted by some Hunter friends he knew from long ago. Sam and Y/N had been together for almost five years now. Y/N was the very jealous type of girlfriend and Sam was very protective. It worked out for both of them.

"I'm asking if we could have a threesome." The girl, Layla, asked them both. Layla came from a very long line of hunters. Sam knew her pretty well before Y/N. This pissed her off a little but she decide to control her temper. "Ya know- it could spice up whatever you guys got going on in the bedroom." She smirked at them both.

"I mean sure." Y/N smiles. She saw Sam excited by the idea and was going to make sure she had Sam mainly to herself.

———————

*smut warning*

Sam watched the two girls kiss. He played with himself. Y/N and Layla were heavily making out. They were already undressed. Layla pulled out a vibrator and dildo. She turned on the vibrator and put it between both of them at their sexes. Y/N gasped at the vibration. She looked over to Sam and moaned. Layla looked at Y/N as she moved herself on the vibrator.

"Fuck, you two look sexy together." Sam groaned, stroking himself. He was moving his hand pretty quick. He looked painfully hardened.

Y/N soon came undone by the vibrator and Layla had it to herself until she came undone as well. "Sam, you should join us now, big boy." She says seductively. Y/N looked at Layla as she was still recovering from the intense orgasm she had from the vibrator.

She watched as Layla gave Sam a blow job. Her jealousy was starting to come back. Sam had his fingers in Layla's hair as he groaned at the use of her mouth. Y/N got down on her knees and started to help Layla with Sam. Sam opened his eyes briefly and gasped at how both of them were giving him a blowjob now.

"Holy fuck-" He says, breath caught in his throat. He started to come undone, seeing Y/N swallow all of it.

"That's a good girl." Layla says. She was really dominant now than the first time they met her tonight. She got up and laid down on the bed. "Now it's time for the best part." She smirked.

Y/N came over to the bed and Layla made her get on all fours. Y/N looked over her shoulder in doggystyle position ready for Sam. "Touch me and fuck her." Layla told Sam. Sam nodded.

He positioned himself at Y/N's core and pushed in. They both groaned. It didn't take long for Sam to fuck the shit out of his girlfriend. He played with Layla's pussy, fingering her and rubbing her clit. She was a moaning mess too, liking the way Sam's fingers played with her.

Layla came undone by Sam's fingers and groaned when he pulled them out. He sucked them clean and he moaned. "So sweet." He says.

The girls then switched positions and Y/N was now getting her pussy played with while Sam fucked Layla. Y/N didn't really mind in the moment since there was a lot of pleasure going on.

Layla kept bouncing her ass back on Sam and Y/N heard him smack it a few times. Y/N couldn't focus on them as Sam curled his fingers in her and hit her g spot which made her come undone.

She was too out of it as she rode Sam's hand to end the orgasm. She was moaning loudly.

Layla moaned and gasped when Sam gripped her hip with his free hand. Sam released his fingers from Y/N and licked them clean. He kept thrusting into Layla. Layla tried to meet him thrust for thrust. Layla gasped again as Sam smacked her ass and came into her. Sam moaned loudly and rubbed her ass cheeks. Layla got off Sam and chuckles. "Got carried away there, huh?" She smirked.

Y/N finally came back to focus after her orgasm passed and she calmed down. She saw Layla and Sam just staring at one another. Y/N looked in between Layla's legs and gasped. She saw Sam's cum ooze out. "Sam, what the fuck?!" She snapped at him. "You weren't supposed to cum in her!" She started yelling.

Sam's eyes widened. "I didn't mean to! I couldn't control myself!" He says. "The pleasure was too good." He said, starting to feel guilty.

"I can't believe you!" Y/N got up and started to dress.

Sam looked at her. "Where are you going!" He quickly got dressed too. Y/N ran out the door with her stuff and had Sam hot on her tail. "Y/N!"

"Go and be with Layla if she's going to fulfill your needs like that. She'll be pregnant in no time, Sam." Y/N says, really heartbroken.

"Y/N, you agreed to having the threesome with us. And when we have sex, we don't use protection half the time because you're on the pill. I kinda just let go without thinking." He told her. "You can't breakup with me over this." He says.

"Really? Because it seemed like you were having way more fun with her!" She accused him.

"You both are equally hot!" Sam argued. They started to get stared at at the party. "I can't do this here with you. Let's go home and figure this out!" Sam says.

"No, Sam. I need a minute to myself." Y/N says and walked away opposite of their car. Sam took a deep breath and held his head in his hands.