Supernatural Imagines

Maybe in Another Life You Were Mine (Sam x Reader)

Summary: Y/N gets trapped in another world and finds herself in a relationship with Sam.

A/N: This might be a short one as I am just making this as I go haha

Y/N was thrown through a door and saw her world disappear right before her eyes. "No!" She screamed. She tried to close and reopen the door but found herself stuck. She felt tears prick her eyes. "No..." she trailed off. She then took in her surroundings.

A motel room with a ruffled bed and someone's bags laid out on the sofa across with their clothes spiraled out. She saw the bathroom light on and the door shut. She had been messing with the closet door. She sighed heavily. "Great. Now this person is going to think I'm some psycho in their room." She mumbled. She got up and sat down on their bed. As she sunk into the mattress, the springs squeaked.

The bathroom door suddenly opened to reveal a muscular man with broad shoulders and a six pack wrapped with a towel around his waist. He saw Y/N and his breath hitched. "Who are you?" He snapped. "This isn't funny." He says.

Y/N stared at him confused. "Sam? It's me, Y/N." She says. She saw him quickly grab his gun. She raised her hands when he cocked it. "Sam!" She snapped. "It's me!" She repeated.

"Y/N, you died. I saw you!" Sam says. "This can't be real!" He said.

"Look, I came through a door and now I'm here. I was fighting Raphael with Dean and yourself." Y/N says. Sam lowered his gun while uncocking it.

"Wait... you're not from this universe? Did you do time travel?" He asked her.

"What? No." Y/N chuckles. She saw the way Sam looked at her. "Look, is there a way I can get back to my world? I need a spell or something!"

Sam frowned. "Y/N... there's no magic here." He says. Y/N's eyes widened.

"Are you fucking with me?" Y/N eyed him.

"I'm not. We managed to seal both Heaven and Hell. We haven't had to deal with them or magic at all." Sam says. "Humanity has been normal. Y/N was good at making sure." He said. He set down the gun on his nightstand. He started to change. "I miss her sometimes..." He mumbled.

"Woah, Sam! Put your weiner away!" Y/N covered her eyes as soon as she saw his bare ass.

Sam frowned and looked over as he put on his boxers. "We're you not...sorry I assumed." He says.

"What? You think I like you?" Y/N peeked through her hands.

"You did. In this world at least." Sam mumbled as he chewed on his lip. He then put on a shirt.

"Oh... I-seriously? I... wow." Y/N says out of words. Sam smiled and sat down next to her.

"You never were to admit it. I had to make the first move." He smirked. Y/N blushed. "Maybe you could learn a lot from yourself by being in my world." Sam whispered as he leaned in.

Y/N's eyes widened when his lips connected with hers. She slowly kissed back and they started to kiss heavily. She then gasped and pushed Sam away. "You still kiss like you used to." He smirked again.

Y/N chuckles nervously. "How'd you know I'd kiss back?"

"Because I know that look on your face... when I was changing, you wanted to desperately see even though you thought you were being a good friend and not looking." Sam chuckles. Y/N's face blushed some more. "You always said I could read you like a book... I've missed your blushy face." He says.

Y/N took a breath. "Are you always this hot?" She breathed out. She pushed his face away playfully when he smirked cutely at her.

Sam chuckles. "Cutie." He mumbled. "You should tell your Sam." He suddenly brought up. "If you ever go back that is..." He mumbled.