Yandere Simulator One Shots Book 2

247: Valentine's Disaster

A continuation of 'Time With My Girls'. Requested by mycatrunsmylife yumissen and GoddessOfChocolate

Amai Odayaka x Oka Ruto x Asu Rito x Muja Kina x Reader:

Valentine's Day was coming up, and you knew all four of your girlfriends would want to spend it with you. You couldn't spend it with all of them though. They didn't know they were all dating you, they only thought it was you and each of them. You didn't have the heart to tell anyone no, so this was going to be difficult.

You decided to talk to Asu first. Maybe make some plans with her for Valentine's Day. You limited yourself to two hours with each girl, plus fifteen minutes to travel to where you planned to meet each of them since you couldn't meet them at the same place because they'd find out about each other. That wouldn't be good.
"Hey Asu." You say as you jog over to her. She looks up at you, a wide smile plastered on her face.
"Hey babe. How are you?" She asks, wrapping an arm around you and kissing your cheek. A light blush forms on your face as she does.
"I'm good. Listen, I wanted to talk about Valentine's Day." She seems to get excited by the mention of Valentine's Day. You don't blame her, although you're not exactly excited. You have to make sure it goes according to my plan, just to make sure they don't find out about each other. "How about we meet up at 10am at the park so we can have a kickabout. Just the two of us." You suggest, knowing that's something she would love.
"I'd love that!" She beamed and hugged you tightly. You laugh a little and hug her back.

The next person you go to meet up with is Amai. She's in the cooking club like usual. You sneak up behind her and wrap your arms around her. She gasped and turned back, hugging you when she realised you'd been the one hugging her.
"Hey sweetheart. What brings you here?" She asks as you both let go.
"I wanted to talk about Valentine's Day. You could come over and we could bake together." You suggest. You made sure your plans with each girl would make them happy. Her eyes light up.
"Even better. You could come to my house!" She suggests happily. You nod your head, knowing that won't change your plans at all. You live about the same distance from the park where you planned to meet Asu. "What time are you coming over?" She asks.
"Umm... is 12:15 okay with you?" You ask her. She nodded her head, hugging you again.
"That's great." You kiss her cheek, saying your goodbyes and heading out.

You go to visit Oka in her occult club next. You tap on the door, not being too loud in case she's doing a ritual. She had told you it was dangerous to interrupt, and you didn't want anything bad to happen to her. After a few minutes, she opens the door and hugs you tightly.
"Hi." She says excitedly. You kiss her forehead as you let her go. She grabs your hand and pulls you inside. You let her.
"You know how it's Valentine's Day soon?" You ask her. She nods her head excitedly. "Do you want to meet at the library and do some occult research together?" You ask her, holding her small hands in yours. She nodded even more excitedly, pulling her hands away and hugging you tightly again.
"I'd love that! Maybe we could do love hexes together too!" She says, her voice mostly muffled in your chest. You smile and play with her hair as she stays close to you.
"We can meet up at 2:30, okay?" You tell her. She nods her head before looking up at you.
"I love you."

The last person you have to meet up with is Muja. You walk into the nurses office, looking at her. She smiles and walks over to you, taking you to a separate part of the room away from the nurse.
"What brings you here babe?" She asks, looking up at you with your hands comfortably in hers.
"Well, Valentine's Day is coming up, and I got us a reservation at 6 for dinner. You interested?" You ask. She smiles and nods her head.
"Sure. Sounds like fun." She tells you. You wanted to say more, but the bell for class went which meant that you couldn't. "See you later." She quickly kisses your cheek and sends you on your way. As you walk to your next class, you get a text message from an anonymous sender telling you to go to the cherry blossom tree straight away after school.

Like the text message wanted, you went to the cherry blossom tree at the back of the school. Your run slowed when you saw all four of your girlfriends stood underneath. This was your worst nightmare. You slowly walk over.
"Hey girls..." you say awkwardly. They all turn to you, looks of anger, heartbreak, and betrayal on their faces. They've found out.
"Who are you dating?" Asu asks angrily. You gulp and step back.
"Umm... all of you?" You say, embarrassed. The truth would come out eventually, and it was better to out it now than hurt everyone later.
"Y-you're cheating!" Amai asked as tears began to run down her cheeks.
"What is wrong with you?" Muja shouted angrily. You look down.
"I couldn't say no to any of you... I'm sorry..." you admit, sighing. You knew this would be the end. They'd never forgive you, you knew that because if you were in their position you wouldn't be able to forgive either.
"There is something seriously wrong with you." Asu said firmly, glaring at you. You can't feel anything but guilt. You looked at Oka, who hasn't spoken a word. She is in complete shock, her face even paler than usual. Seconds later, she fainted and fell to the floor. "You should leave." Asu said firmly as the other two made sure Oka was okay. You sigh and walk away slowly, glancing back at your former partners.
"I'm sorry..."