Pretender (Posie)

Chapter 6

Penelope got out of the car and grabbed Josie's wrist. She put her other hand on Josie's waist before she kissed her. She pulled away but Josie put her hand on the back of Penelope's head connecting their lips again. It's strange even though they just met today kissing each other felt so right like it was something that they were supposed to do.

"We can't tell Lizzie," Josie told Penelope which made her smirk.

"Fine," leans in and whispers in her ear, "but you have to go on a date with me on this Friday."

"Nobody can know," Josie states, "I mean nobody."

"Is this your way of telling me you like me?" She smirked again.

"No, if I liked you then I would tell you," Josie states bringing Penelope back into the party.

"Hey Josie, umm," hope gave a confused look at Penelope," New girl? Do you want to play truth or dare with us?" Hope asks.

"No, don't invite fucking Satan incarnate to the game," Lizzie hissed glaring at Penelope.

"Creative," Penelope whispered to Josie. Causing her to smile slightly.

"This is a good thing, you can dare her to do something stupid," Hope loudly whispers into Lizzie's ear.

"Fine, Penelope can join."

"And she used my real name I feel like she's finally starting to like me." Penelope said sarcastically to Josie.

Penelope and Josie sat next to each other. Penelope on her left and Hope on her right. Rafael decided to play too, so he brought a bottle to spin so that we wouldn't keep choosing the same person over and over again.

Rafael decided to go firsts because it was his party. He spun the bottle and it landed on Landon.  Landon chose truth.

"Umm... how do you feel about Hope," Raf asks.

"Umm...I still have strong feelings for her," Landon confesses smirking in Hopes direction

Lizzie looked unsettled when he said that and Hope didn't say anything she just looked at Lizzie.

"Landon.... I don't feel the same way. I'm sorry... I like someone else," she whispered still making eye contact with Lizzie.

Penelope noticed this interaction and continued to watch them for the rest of the time until it was her turn.  She knew there was something up. And when it was finally her turn she spun the bottle and made sure it landed on Lizzie.

"Hmm... look who I landed on."

"Dare, Throw everything you got at me,"Lizzie seemed confident.

"Alright, I dare you to make-out hope," Penelope smirked.

"What?" Lizzie seemed a little less confident, "I have a boyfriend."

"I'm sure it's okay with him, right?" Penelope looked at Raf. 

"Yeah, I'm fine with it, it's not like you're actually into girls so it should be okay, Right?" Rafael says

"I really don't mind Lizzie," Hope says staring at her lips.

"Umm.. okay," Lizzie got closer to Hope close enough that their lips could almost touch.

"Hey relax it's not like we haven't done this before," Hope whispered very quietly against Lizzie's lips so that only Lizzie could  hear her.

"Okay." Lizzie slowly connected their lips. It didn't take long for the kiss to become heated. Lizzie was captivated by Hope's lips against hers. Hope started to push her down and slipped her tongue into Lizzie's mouth. She didn't want to stop. She didn't know if she could, it wasn't until Hope slid her hand underneath Lizzie shirt that she got brought back to reality and slightly pushed Hope off of her. "Are you happy now?" Lizzie asked wiping her lips.

"Very," Penelope smirked.

Josie's Pov

It was now my turn and I landed on Rafael.

"Truth or dare?"

"Truth."

"Is it true that you umm... love my sister and would do anything for her, " I said.  I didn't want to do anything too extreme so that was going to have to work for now

"Of course I care about Lizzie and I would do mostly anything to make her happy."

A few minutes later Mg spun the bottle and it landed on me

"Okay, I dare you to do a body shot with Penelope."

"No! My sister is not doing a body shot with, with satan, pick something else!" Lizzie yelled.

"Umm... Okay, then I dare her to make out with Hope, "

"What! No! You can't do something that's already been done!"Lizzie shouts

"Wait, " I said but nobody heard me.

"It's either that or the body shot."

"Why is Lizzie deciding for me?!"I asked.

Penelope smirked at me.

"Josie can I talk to you for a second? alone, " Lizzie said as she grabbed my hand and led me to the hallway.

"What?" I asked her.

"We should leave, " she said, "It's really late and Hope's mom is probably getting worried. "

"It's 10:30, you just want to leave because you don't want me to do the dare!"

"Of course I don't want you to do the dare. Either of them because it's either a body shot with satan or make out with the person I," she cleared her throat, "with umm Hope."

"What?" I asked.

"Nothing."

"No what were you about to say?"

"Hey, the somebody called for a noise complaint so the party is over, " Raf told us.

"Thank god, " Lizzie said, "Now we have to leave."

"Fine, I'll meet you in the car, I have to talk to someone really quickly."