*EDITING!* Creepypasta X reader one shots *COMPLETED*

Ticci Toby *EDITED*

Pity was the last thing that any killer would want from a person let alone people like them. It was an insult to their character and possibly bruise their ego. However, your blood was boiling when you heard the other's talk about his tics to his face and whenever he wasn't around. Specifically Ben and Jeff. He heard them one day- even though you were pretty sure they wanted him to hear them- and he slashed his toma-hawks across their stomachs and to this day they don't talk about him, at least when he's no where near by. He had a tough life and he doesn't need them added onto the list. You don't feel too bad cause he can handle himself and his killing skills are off the charts. Eh, what do you expect from a mass murderer? Anything less? You don't think so. You really admired him and found it adorable how much he loved pancakes and waffles and his cute orange goggles. Your admiration turned into a crush and now you're head over heels. You was resentful at first because you thought that he loved Clockwork, but was pleasantly surprised to find out that he doesn't like her in that way since he sees her as a sister. That came as a relief for you, anyway you are walking with said person in the woods. You came back from killing about an hour ago and he just wanted to escape the craziness of the mansion needing some much needed peace, so you accompanied him. You saw this as an opportunity to get alone time with him. You swung your hands close to his hands making them touch until eventually you were holding hands. You thought that he was going to pull away, but when you gave him a side glance didn't seem phased. That was a positive sign so you walked for awhile until Toby stopped and he faced you. You looked at him concerned believing that something's wrong and you jumped the gun.
"What's the matter?" He looked at you a bit uncertain before heaving a sigh
"Nothing, I want to show you my face." You said nothing as he took the hood off along with the goggles and lastly the mouth-guard. You were pleasantly surprised, he was handsome in every way. He had such beautiful soft brown eyes with luscious brown hair. He also had a chunk of his face missing exposing the left side of his teeth and cheek muscle but that didn't matter to you. He stared at you for a response ticking violently while blushing. When you ran your hand through his hair his ticking calmed down considerably "You're the first person I showed."
"Really?" He nodded. "I feel special"
"You are special." He was ticking a little bit more despite you rubbing his scalp "Y/N I understand if you don't feel the same way." You was confused and a bit surprise at the lack of stuttering from his tics until he pressed his lips to yours. You stood frozen but soon responded before he can pull away and it soon turned heated with him holding you tight against him and your arms around his neck. You let go once air became necessary and you looked at him.
"I love you Toby" His eyes widen at you before softening a bit
"I love you too Y/N" He hugged you and whispered in your ear "Would you be my girlfriend?"
You responded by kissing him and you felt his smile against your lips.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Edited 2/18/19