Ben Drowned X Reader X Ticci Toby

3K 58 33
                                    


A/N: I'm going to make it work the way I made EJ and Splendorman work XD

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"What exactly am I going to do with myself now?" You were contemplating what you wanted to do today, you wanted to do something different instead of making pancakes and sitting at the table on your phone playing games or listening to music on your tablet "Maybe I can make myself some waffles and play some video games." You thought about it for a minute before going along with the plan. You went to the fridge and got the frozen waffles and made yourself five (I once ate 6 waffles like the fat ass I am and I regret nothing). You served yourself orange juice and grabbed the syrup plopping yourself on the couch and watching Link and Ben play video games.

"GET OUTTA MY WAY YOU LINK REJECT!" Ben physically shoved Link who growled and elbowed him back

"I'm going to win this race whether you like it or not you damn midget!" They were both shoving each other back and forth and just when Ben was about to win Link shoved him hard enough to tip over and Link came in first place with Ben in close second.

"YOU ARE A PIECE OF SHIT!" Ben was about to tackle Link when you butted in

"Calm down Ben." He turned on you calming a little but still riled up

"But he-" You shook your head

"You cheat all the time and no one doesn't really do anything, he shoves you once and he gets in first and you come in second you wanna fight him. It's not that big of a deal we hate it the same way when a victim gets away we hate it with a passion but sometimes in life shit happens and we're murderers since when is luck ever on our side?" Ben just stared at you as you gave him a grin and he looked down with a blush mumbling to his self

"A-are t-those w-waffles?" You jumped ten feet in the air looking beside you to see Toby scoffing down the remainder of your waffles.

"Hey! I had 2 left!" Toby ignored you as he inhaled them and then gave a loud burp

"I'll m-make more w-when we g-get back l-let's go." He grabbed your hand and you were only able to grab your phone and knife before heading into the woods

"Who are we going to kill?" He rushed some more until you couldn't see the mansion no more and he stopped to look at you.

"N-no one j-just wanted to t-talk to y-you." You nodded catching your breath and turning to stare at him glad it was dark so he couldn't see your blushing cheeks

"What you wanted to tell me Toby?" You tilted your head and he rubbed the back of his neck removing his mouthguard and goggles.

"Aah w-w-well y-you s-see... I have a-"

"YOU SAID WE WERE GOING TO DO IT TOGETHER!" You shrieked bloody murder as Ben popped his head out of your phone. You dropped it and he pulled his self out grabbing your phone holding it towards you

"WHAT THE FUCK POSSESSED YOU TO FOLLOW ME IN MY PHONE!" You knocked him on his head and he rubbed it pouting

"We had a deal! He promised we were going to do it together!" You squinted your eyes confused

"What are you jabbering about? Tell me what together?" They stood silent staring at each other before looking at you "Well?" They both sighed and it was freaking you out a little

"We like you"

"W-we l-like y-you." They both said it at the same time and your jaw went completely slack. They liked you? Huh? Toby doesn't like Natalie? Ben doesn't like Sally? Que?

"Huh? What? Sally? Natalie?" Toby shook his head

"She's a lesbian." You jerked surprised at that new information

"Sally is like a sister to me." You nodded your head accepting it and you looked at them still pondering your decision

"Yeah I know this is awkward but we were wondering if-"

"Y-you would g-go out w-with u-us?" You stood quiet looking between the both of them before smiling to yourself

"I wasn't expecting this but I do like the both of you on some degree and I would like to see how this would play out." They heaved a sigh of relief laughing a little.

"W-will waffles p-persuade you m-more?" Your eyes lit up at the thought of food

"And games?" That's it you're in

"LEAD THE WAY!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What do you think?

*EDITING!* Creepypasta X reader one shots *COMPLETED*Where stories live. Discover now