My Enemy - M.P

Part 43

Y/n's POV

"Let me check if I got everything. You're constantly thinking if it was right to kill Hunter. Em's words are still hurting you. My little brother just confessed his love for your little sister"

"And he gave her a nickname!"

"And he gave her a nickname, Am. You heard them smooch, ew btw"

"Exactly"

"You think they have been in love since we moved here, but they haven't confessed because we two didn't get along. Ale couldn't hide his love anymore and confessed to Amber today, and now they are together"

I nodded my head to confirm that he had caught everything I had told him

"I'm struggling to get one thing right though", he said and lifted his forehead from mine, looking me directly in the eyes. "You said "you" earlier, when I asked what was going through your mind. Tell me what my role in this is. How have I made you confused?"

My gaze flickered away from him. I didn't want to answer this question.

Hands captured my face, and his thumbs stroked my cheeks. "I haven't made you confused because I was pretending to ignore you in the living room? I swear I was just joking. You don't know how hard it was to keep my eyes away from you"

A soft laugh escaped my lips at his admission, and I looked back at him. "It's not that. It really is nothing Mattia"

"Don't tell me it's nothing. Did I say or do something?", he asked as he scanned my face for an answer, voice coated in worry. "Did I really fuck up our relationship on the first day?"

"What are you talking about? Of course not. You did nothing wrong. I'm just overthinking everything today", I truthfully answered.

The worry in his eyes remained. "Are you regretting telling me that you don't hate me?"

Shaking my head, I reached out and brushed his hair away from his forehead. "Never. I will never regret telling you how I feel"

A shaky breath left his lips and he leaned into my touch.

We were standing like that for a few minutes before he broke the silence. "You wanna know something crazy"

"Tell me"

"I fell in love with five people"

My hand froze against his forehead, and as my eyes found him, my heart clenched. 

Five people. He fell in love with five people.

Why was he telling me this?

"I fell in love with five and are still in love with them all"

Why the hell was he saying this to me?

"You wanna know who?"

I looked away from him.

No. I don't want to know who you have loved. I don't want to know who you still are in love with. But before I could say that, he started speaking.

"The first one is my enemy"

What?

"Second one is my first love"

This can't be.

"Third one is my best friend that has always wanted to murder me"

Is he for real?

"Fourth one is my Hart"

A shallow breath left my lips.

"And last but not least is my Y/n"

My eyes found his as he said my name, and a mischievous glint appeared on his face.