The Outsiders | Preferences

When You Cheat On Him (𝒹𝑒𝓉𝒶𝒾𝓁𝑒𝒹)

Johnny: 

You were at your friend's birthday party. A group of about ten people, including you, were playing Spin the Bottle. Johnny wasn't there. 

You really didn't want to play the game, but your friend made you, saying, "Come on, it's my birthday. I would do it for you." You told her, "Ok, but I'm not going to kiss anyone. I have a boyfriend." And she said, "Oh, please, you need to stop holding on to Johnny. He's too innocent for you. You need some action." You rolled your eyes.

A tall boy with blond hair and green eyes spins and it lands on... you.

"Kiss, kiss, kiss!" everyone chants and you shake your head, holding firm.

"Oh, come on, why won't you kiss me?" the blond-haired guy says.

"NO. I have a boyfriend, I already told all of you this. I am NOT going to cheat."

"It's not cheating, it's just a game," your friend says.

"Stop, I won't kiss him!" you screech. Suddenly, in one fell swoop, he advances toward you, gives you a swift kiss, and pulls away with a satisfied expression on his face. You gasp and run out of the house and all the way home.

You wipe your lips ferociously before running into the house, immediately searching for Johnny.

"Baby, where are you?" you call out.

"My darling," he says. You see him and run into his arms. You're already crying into his chest. "Omg, sweetheart, what happened? Why are you crying?"

"I- I- my friend made me play that dumb game spin the bottle, and I- this random boy kissed me, even though I told him I had a boyfriend," you blurt out. He pulls away from you for a second, hesitant to believe you. Then he shakes his head, as if he's thinking, Why wouldn't I believe my own girlfriend?

He hugs you back to his chest, and strokes your hair. 

"Come on, baby, let's go watch a movie. Everything's gonna be ok, sweetheart," he tells you, and cuddles with you for the rest of the night.

Dally:

Sylvia had recently come over to Dally's house one day, asking to talk. The next thing you know, they're the best of friends. They have been hanging out together almost every day, and you notice he's spending a lot more time with her than with you. 

At first, you try not to let jealousy get the best of you. But as time goes on, Sylvia and Dally become wayyy too close. I mean, Dally has canceled at least three dates you guys had planned to hang out with Sylvia. They start hugging really tight after every time they say goodbye to each other, and sometimes, Dally can't keep his hands to himself, if you know what I mean...

It's getting worse and worse, and you barely see Dally anymore. You two haven't had $ex in a couple of months and he barely gives you affection anymore. So, you decide to get it somewhere else...

You went to Tim Shepard's place and asked to sleep with him. He voluntarily agreed and you immediately felt guilty. You felt bad the entire time, but you kept telling yourself, "It serves Dally right." You come home and Dally doesn't even notice you're gone.

A couple days later, you and Dally meet Tim on the street. When Tim sees you, he gives you a little wink, but Dally doesn't seem to notice.

"Hey, man, how are you doin'?" Tim asks Dally.

Dally says, "Not bad."

"Uh, are you two still together?" Tim says. You immediately freeze.

"Yeahhh, why?" Dally asks, with an If you say one wrong word, I will beat you to a pulp expression on his face.