utah || hemmings au {sequel to camp || hemmings au}

nine

A/N: okay before i start I just wanna say so that you wont get confused that this is gonna be the second part of the previous chapter in Luke's pov

As I pulled into the parking lot of the burger joint that Audrey and I usually came to, I was dreading going in. Audrey was great really, but I had better things I could be doing. Like hooking up with this really cute girl that was in my History class. Sarah, or something was her name. I really didn't know how I got away with cheating, I guess the girls I hooked up with could care less about telling anyone. I don't know, it was a mystery to even me.

I got out of my car and made my way to the doors of the joint, stopping briefly as I saw who was sat with Audrey. I recomposed myself and stepped in, making my way over to the two girls. Audrey smiled brightly at me, as I saw Caroline turn around and mutter something under her breath. Most likely a smart comment, she was good for those.

"Hey, cutie." Audrey giggled as I sat down in the chair beside her.

I gave her a small smile back and kissed her cheek softly. "Hey, babe." I let my eyes travel to Caroline and I nodded at her, "Hi, Caroline."

"Hey, Luke." She smiled at me, but I could tell it was forced. I wanted to be a bastard and say something, but that would blow my cover with Audrey, so I held back.Audrey began to ramble on about didlfferent things and honestly, I wasn't paying attention. She had lost me minutes ago, my mind was stuck on the black haired girl in front of me. She was watching Audrey as she talked, but I could tell that she was just as uninterested as I was. After about fifteen minutes, Audrey told us she had to go to the bathroom and left Caroline and I alone. I didn't know what to say to her, I wasn't sorry for kissing her, so there was no sense in saying that. So we just stayed silent for a while, until I decided to say something.

"So, I'm guessing you didn't tell her." I said, causing Caroline to look up at me from her drink.

"Wow, you're very perceptive." She rolled her eyes at me.

I glared at her and then softened, knowing I wasn't going to get anywhere by being my rude self. "Well, she hasn't ripped my throat out, so I just assumed."

"Audrey didn't tell me you were coming." She stirred her straw around in her soda, and pieces of her hair fell into her face.

"Audrey didn't tell me you were going to be here." I rested my arms on the table and folded them across each other.

"Well, I guess we both got a surprise, huh?" Caroline laughed mocking, something she did to me a lot.

"Yeah," I nodded. I began to fiddle around with the bracelets on my wrists, tracing the band names that were inscribed in them. "Why didn't you tell her?"

Caroline shrugged her shoulders. "I figured that you might like to tell her yourself. You know, if you ever decide to come clean. Will you ever come clean?"

My head snapped up and I stared at blankly at her. I opened my mouth to speak, then shut it quickly. There was no way I was going to tell Audrey anything I had ever done. It was mostly because I didn't want to break her heart. Why would I care about that? Well, we had been together for a while and I actually did care about her feelings, believe it or not. And also if Audrey found out, she would kill me, and I knew I couldn't stop what I was doing. I didn't know what was wrong with me, I liked Audrey. But I also liked a lot of other girls, including Caroline. Do you see my problem?

"That's what I thought." Caroline replied harshly, her eyes trailing to the bathrooms. I looked also and saw Audrey approaching us. I cleared my throat and sat up straighter in my seat as she reached the table.

"I'm back," Audrey chirped as she sat down at the table. She reached over and grabbed my hand, intertwining our fingers. I gave her a smile and she grinned back at me. She really was beautiful. "So, what did you guys talk about while I was gone?" Audrey's eyes darted back and forth between Caroline and I.

"You." Caroline said cooly, taking a long sip from her almost empty cup of soda. My heart stopped for a minute because I was about 99% sure she was about to tell Audrey evrrything.

"All good things, right?" Audrey laughed.

"Very good things." I nodded quickly and glanced at Caroline as I said it, hoping she would play along. She rolled her eyes at me, but I knew Audrey hadn't seen as she was still staring lovingly at me.

Caroline knew I was a cheater, my girlfriend didn't. Caroline knew I was a jerk, again my girlfriend didn't. You see, that was a huge problem for me.

Why?

Because I wanted Caroline more than I wanted my own girlfriend.

---

Unedited

wHAT i got bored so i updated...

But good stuff is happening soon!!

-falloutcalum :)