The Umbrella Academy Preferences

Five Imagine: "Don't keep secrets!"

You and Five have been going steady for almost 3 months and he's been acting really strange. He's been secretive and won't explain to you why he has to cancel some of your dates or randomly cut them short. You were getting really tired of it so you decided to confront him about it.

He invited you over to his place for the first time and you were nervous. You'd only met his family once and that was it. Something about they were all really busy according to Five. That was strange to you but you shrugged it off.

You finished getting ready and headed out the door to the academy. It was a nice autumn day so you were taking in the cool air. Surprisingly he lives only two blocks from your place and the walk was only 10 minutes. You went up to the front door and knocked.

"Who is it?" A voice asked from the other side.

"Um...Y/N? I'm here for Five?" You called.

The door swung open to reveal Luther. You smiled at him and he let you inside.

"He's with Diego doing some stuff. You can go wait in the sitting area if you want, he should be back anytime. Klaus is in there with Ben." He explained, leading you to the sitting area.

"Why hey there!" Klaus greeted, hugging you.

You awkwardly hugged back and waved at Ben who kindly waved back.

"Have a seat. How've you been?" Ben asked, patting the couch.

You sat down and engaged in talking with them. Ben and Klaus were actually really nice and you got along great with them. They told you jokes and some stories while you waited for your boyfriend to arrive.

"So, have you and our bro kissed?" Klaus asked.

You turned red. Truth is you hadn't and didn't know why. Maybe because you both were too awkward? Shy? Or maybe he just didn't want to kiss you?

You shook your head, "Not yet..."

"Five's just a weird guy, man. Listen, he doesn't kiss you we'll put hot sauce in his underwear." Klaus replied.

Suddenly Five zapped into the living room, startling you and confusing you.

"Touch my underwear and you're dead." Five grumbled.

You blinked a couple of times. Were you just seeing things? Five just zapped into the living room out of thin air. You rubbed your eyes and they widened.

"H-How did you-" You stammered.

Five's head snapped to your direction and his face went white. Klaus and Ben quickly left the room but you knew they'd be eavesdropping from somewhere. You two just stared at each other, the room so quiet you could hear a pin drop.

"Y/N, I can explain..." He told you, stepping towards you.

You stood up and backed up, "Y-You just...out of nowhere...h-how?"

He sighed, "I told you it's a long story..."

You blinked at him, "What are you?"

He scratched his neck and shook his head, "I can't tell you.."

"B-But I just saw-"

"Unsee it."

You clenched your fists. How could he keep this from you? You started to get angry and he could tell, which resulted in a stare down. You felt hurt that he didn't bother to tell you or mention anything about it.

"Are you kidding me?!" You snapped.

"No, I'm not-"

"Five I'm your girlfriend! Or at least I thought I was-"