(Sequel) You and I | 70s Teen Dream Story

Chapter 75

With Andy's birthday a few days away, I was busy planning his day. He didn't wanna go out anywhere. He wanted to stay home and have me make a cake and dinner for him. It was going to be a lowkey day.

"So you don't wanna go out at all and celebrate?" I asked Andy who was currently tuning his guitar.

"Nope I wanna stay in these four walls and spend my birthday with you," Andy replied as he looked up at me.

"Then it's all settled for your birthday. But now my next question is, what sort of cake do you want?"  I asked him.

Andy smiled and paused as he thought for a moment.

"Well something chocolate?" Andy asked curiously.

"We can do that. What would like to have for dinner that day?" I followed up.

Andy paused as he stared at me.

"Can't I have you for dinner?" Andy joked while he smirked at me.

I rolled my eyes.

"Andrew!"I  scolded.

"Sorry darling I couldn't contain myself," Andy said as he laughed.

"In all seriousness, what do you want for your birthday dinner?" I asked him once more.

"To be honest, anything sounds good. You could cook the phone book and I'd eat it contently," Andy replied.

"Ok then I'll make it a surprise," I replied as I made mental notes for his upcoming birthday.

"I think you are a pro at that," Andy remarked.

"I learned from the best," I told him proudly.

Andy put his guitar down so he could focus on me and my questions.

"So what do you have planned for the day of my birthday?" Andy asked.

"It's all a surprise," I told him with a wink.

Andy chuckled.

"Woman of mine, I swear," Andy mumbled.

"What?" I asked chuckling.

"You drive me crazy if you can't tell," Andy commented as he scooted closer to me.

"It's all part of the plan," I replied nonchalantly.

"Plan?" Andy asked.

"Yep and I think it's working very very well," I replied.

Andy chuckled as he wrapped an arm around me contently. 

He gave me a side hug as we stayed quiet for a few minutes.

"So you don't even want your parents or sister popping by on your birthday?" I asked him.

Andy shook his head.

"Not to be rude but as busy as I have been darling, I just want to be alone with you," Andy remarked.

I smiled.

"Ok we will do that but you gotta set those boundaries with them not me," I commented.

"I will darling," Andy replied as he kissed the top of my head.

I sighed contently. He didn't have to do much to make me feel safe.

"So it's all set for your birthday," I told him.

"I can't wait," Andy mumbled.

"Oh you are going to love your birthday present," I commented.

"I am? Hmmmm I wonder what it could be," Andy pondered.

"You'll have to wait and find out," I told him with a smirk. 

"God woman," Andy mumbled near my ear.

I shook my head at Andy's comment.

"In due time you will find out," I told him.

In all honesty, I had planned a trip to Florida again for his birthday. He deserved to be with his brothers for once without the pressure of fame.

"It sounds like a wonderful surprise darling," Andy told me happily.

"It will be as long as the weather works out," I hinted at.

"Weather working out? Hmm," Andy pondered. 

"You'll find out,' I told him happily.

He smiled so big at me.

"You are the best. I always have to tell ya that," Andy remarked.

"And it makes my heart soar," I told him.

"(Y/N) I plan to do that the rest of your life," Andy commented.

"You used my real name?" I asked shocked.

"Yes (Y/N) because I'm serious. Sometimes you got to be serious," Andy replied.

I turned to look at him as his eyes glistened with love.

"I love you, Andrew," I told him.

"And I love you so much (Y/N)," Andy commented before he held my face in his hands and stole a few kisses.

I closed my eyes contently at his moves.

Andy pulled away and stared at me.

"Never change darling," Andy whispered.

"I don't plan on it," I replied

To a loving afternoon with my husband.