Torn Between Two Riddles (RIDDLES x READER FANFIC)

Chapter 55: Halloween

Y/N-

The kiss was soft and slow filled with passion and care rather than hate and frustration like our kisses usually were.

When he did pull away he rested his forehead on mine and looked into my eyes, "are you okay?" He whispered.

I nodded.

He let out a small smile and went to get up from the bed, but I gripped his arm stopping him. I didn't have to say anything. One look in his eye and he smiled, laying down and pulling me with him.

This time he laid on his back pulling me against his chest with his arm around me. His fingers ran through my hair.

And we fell asleep.

As the light started to peek through the window my eyes fluttered open. Immediately meeting Mattheo's as he glared at me from his bed. We'd woken up with my back pressed against Tom and his arm slung over me.

I looked up at him and he was still asleep.

I turned back to Mattheo. His stares never leaving me. I heard him mutter the spell linking our minds,

"What do you want Theo?" I watched the smirk play on his lips.

"And we are back to Theo. Good girl."

"F*ck you"

"Oh I will. In time my love. And you can bet there will be a punishment for every night you've woken up next to him."

"Punishment? You won't do shit."

"Wanna bet?"

"Yeah actually I do. Because I'm not going to fall for your game and deal with the constant pity party you want to throw yourself."

"Watch your words witch!"

"No."

"I swear I will Crucio you in that bed right f*cking now."

"Try me." And the spell dropped.

He sat up in bed fast and walked over to my bed, I pressed myself backwards against Tom instinctively. Theo grabbed my wrist and Tom's hand clasped around his.

I looked up and Tom's eyes shot open meeting Mattheo's.

"I'm not a piece of property that you two get to constantly fight over and claim." I tried to pull my wrist free, but Theo didn't let go and instead just stood there smirking down at me.

I felt Tom's other hand trace up the inside of my thigh slowly, sending shivers down my spine. He leaned in and pressed his lips against my ear, "you sure about that darling."

"I-"

"Think about your next words.... Very carefully." Theo said letting go of my wrist.

I don't know what to say to that!

No I'm not sure...... but also I'm not going to just sit by and watch them fight over me.

I rolled my eyes and got up, surprisingly they let me.

I went to get dressed and climbed back in bed, "what are you doing we have class?" Tom asked.

"Correction. You two have class. Umbridge already passed me."

Theo let out a small laugh and Tom turned gazing into my eyes confused. "Let's just say after the little stunt she tried pulling I set the record straight."