Undertale Love Stories

Dreammare| Not As It Seems

Everyone thought Dream was a good person. That he was the better brother out of him and Nightmare. That he was innocent and sweet. That Nightmare would corrupt him. They weren't too wrong, but they were off by one thing.

Nightmare wasn't the one corrupting Dream. Dream was corrupting Nightmare.

Sure, after eating the Dark Apple, he took the title King of Fear. Sure, he terrorized and destroyed AUs. Sure, he was a villain, but he only learned those things from Dream. Dream made an unbalance in their village, Dream took a title of God, Dream did everything he could to keep people away from his brother. Nightmare was only doing what he had seen done.

Dream knew this, and at first, he was horrified by what had been done! At what his brother had done to their home, to other AUs! Then... He found it so adorable~ He found it attractive~ Of course, he kept this a secret from the other two. He didn't want them to know his twisted thoughts. He didn't want them to know that he was the worse twin.

However, he didn't keep these thoughts and feelings from his twin.

"You terrorized another AU again~" Dream's voice was sickly sweet, him holding his corrupted brother's face. "What a good boy~ Their fear felt so wonderful~ It sent shivers down my spine~"

Nightmare had his eye closed, basking in Dream's touch. In his praises. Now their home was gone, Dream's attention and praises were all on him. He hadn't meant to eat the apples or destroy the tree, but he was glad he had. He liked having Dream touch and praise him. It hurt him when he had to pretend to be this big, evil mastermind, that he hated his brother. He didn't hate his brother! He loved him, he loved him so much that not having his attention was killing him!

"Now, now~ There's no need to cry~" Dream's soothing voice called out, his thumb wiping away Nightmare's tears. "Are you thinking about to the village?" A nod was his answer. "Oh, Brother~ You don't have to think about that place anymore~ And once me and the Stars capture you and your friends~" Dream stopped, his magic expelling outward in a lustful frenzy. All the things he could do once again~

Nightmare shivered at the aura, happily drowning in it. He loved the sense of his brother's twisted aura. Not because it made him stronger, but because it showed him that Dream still loved him.

Dream soon had to leave and go back to the Star Sanses, before leaving he gave the taller skeleton a passionate kiss that was returned happily.

This secret though, was soon discovered by the other two. They had grown curious about where Dream goes every week. So, when he left, they followed. What they saw, surprised them to say the least. To see Nightmare clinging to Dream like a child and Dream's twisted aura reaching out to surround the two of them... Nor were the expecting to hear sinister words whispering in such a praising tone.

"B-Brother... I... I'm getting hot..." Nightmare muttered, nuzzling his blushing face into the other's chest.

Dream laughed sweetly, tilting that embarrassed face up.

"It's alright~ Why don't you kidnap me for a little while~? I can help you with your heat then." The brighter brother offered.

Nightmare gave a purring sound, his tentacles lazily twitching in happiness before he laid down and relaxed. He liked kidnapping Dream; it gave them a beautiful time together while keeping the appearances of being enemies. He couldn't wait for Dream's team to win and him be trapped with Dream as his beautiful warden.

Dream watched as Nightmare's body twitched, a body being summoned underneath his baggy clothes. He didn't need to ask to know what was causing his magic to react the way it was. It was truly adorable~ He too couldn't wait to have Nightmare as his prisoner~ Forever with him and no one daring to get between them~

The hidden Star Sanses watched as Dream tilted his head back, licking his lips greedily as that twisted aura grew. Nightmare whimpered at it, sitting up some and looking up at Dream with a pleading eye.

"C-Can I?" His voice was weak and soft, delicate and docile.

The golden Guardian's face morphed into a prideful look. "Of course~ You caused it, you must fix it~" And without a second thought or hesitation, Dream's glowing cock was pulled out of the confines of his pants before being swallowed impatiently by the King of Fear.

The Star Sanses left soon after that. They then waited at the shared home, talking it over amongst themselves. They were talking about what they saw, what it meant for them, what else were they hiding, etc. By the time Dream reappeared, they had already come to a dark conclusion.

 The next battle was over long before it could begin, the Stars' soft and kind facade falling away as they gave the Dark Sanses a true look at who they were.

Dream grabbed Nightmare by the back of his head and smashed their lips together. The gooey brother didn't bother to fight it, instead melting into it and happily moaning for more.

The Dark Sanses gave confused looks, they hadn't expected that. Nor had they expected the dark aura to leave Dream while something akin to happiness left Nightmare. The other surprise was when Ink pulled Error close to him and gave him a hearty kiss as well, purposely rebooting the glitch. He had giggled darkly before leaving quickly while his prize was still dazed. Blue then grabbed Dust, giving him such a heated look that the insane skeleton openly shivered. They too were soon gone.

Dream and Nightmare soon pulled away from each other, looking at the remaining trio of Dark Sanses. Dream chuckled at their bewildered and terrified expressions. He loved the sense of fear that pooled from others.

"You're no longer needed~ You can enjoy your lives in whatever AU as long as it doesn't disturb us~" With a harsh wave of his hand, the trio quickly teleported away. They didn't need to be told that if they stayed, they would've died.

Nightmare lightly clung to Dream, nuzzling his head under Dream's chin. His body was burning at this point. Seeing and hearing Dream be his truest self in front of the others, to kiss him so passionately~! He needed attention!

The golden Guardian chuckled, easily picking up his larger twin. "Don't worry~ We're going to our home~"

With all those words, neither Guardian was properly seen again. Nor was the Creator or Destroyer. The only ones to be seen of the Star Sanses was Blue, who lived a happy and peaceful life in a deadly AU with Dust by his side. Thankfully, no AU was in danger, so no one truly cared about the missing Sanses. If they were in danger... The Star Sanses wouldn't be too happy with that threat.