Chapter 11: The Cat and the Dare

3.4K 132 7
                                        

Enna's ice cream dropped onto the ground and Logan was left holding her empty cone

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

Enna's ice cream dropped onto the ground and Logan was left holding her empty cone.

"Wh-wha-what?" She stuttered. Peter looked at her, horrified. Remus looked down at the fallen ice cream and scratched behind his ear.

James and Sirius took her by the arms and dragged her into an alleyway, Remus and Peter following.

"What the- he's a rat?!"

She turned to Peter.

"You're a rat?!"

She turned back to the two boys.

"He's a rat!!!"

"Yell it, will ya?" Sirius asked.

"I don't understand- that- that is not normal." Logan laughed nervously. She played with her necklace.

"Listen, Logan what we are about to tell you, you cannot tell anyone else, understood?"

She nodded.

"Peter is an animagus."

"Oh my gosh! Isn't that-"

"Illegal." Remus finished. She shook her head.

"Wow... wait, that explains the nickname, Wormtail... wait, are you all animagus?"

"Maybe..." Sirius said.

"Can you... show me?" She asked, timidly.

The four boys looked at each other before transforming, all except for Remus. Logan looked at him in confusion.

"I'm not one, just them." He explained, pointing to the black dog, stag, and rat. Logan nodded her head, believing his story because he was the most levelheaded out of all of them.

"I can't believe this!" Logan said, walking out of the alleyway with the four boys- all humans now. She looked down on the sidewalk at the puddle that was once Enna's ice cream.

Logan sighed and ordered her a new strawberry ice cream just as Enna walked back out of the restroom.

"What happened?" She asked, looking at the puddle on the sidewalk.

"I dropped your ice cream." Logan explained, "Sorry."

And she handed the girl a new one.

"That's fine, thanks for ordering me a new one."

"No problem." Logan smiled.

She walked down the sidewalk with her ice cream cone in hand, discussing their next prank, while Enna followed behind them. Enna stopped in front of one of the shops and asked to go in.

"You go ahead, I'll wait out here." Logan said, sitting on a bench. She took out the small bag of purple candies she had purchased at Honeydukes.

"Oh, can I have one?!" Peter asked. Logan smiled and shook her head.

The Finder That Couldn't Be FoundWhere stories live. Discover now