written in the stars

Chapter 6

       

Tyler's POV

"I don't remember." I lie rubbing the back of my neck. It was my tell sign I was nervous.

"You fucking asshole. You're fucking kidding me. Right? You didn't fuck my little sister." Jamie asks as he pushes my shoulders.

"We were drunk." I start, "And one thing lead to another. It was only once. She was just as into as I was." 

"You're serious? Holy shit." He throws a punch and before he can throw the second Demers comes running up. My nose was bleeding but I didn't want to make a scene as I knew I was in the fault here, "She's 18. She's confused and lost, and you took advantage of that!"

"Guys, separate." He says as he puts himself between us.

"Get away from me." Jamie nearly shouts as he tries to get to me again, "That's my baby sister." Demers holds him back and that's my queue to leave, "I'm going to fucking kill you!" He shouts as I run out of the club. I go back to my hotel room and clean everything up before going to the gym to work off some energy.

I was in love with Susannah. I knew it. From the moment I was willing to fight my best friend for her, I knew it. As I got off of the treadmill I realized I had been running for a few hours. I went out and Jamie was sitting waiting by my door.

"We need to talk." He says, "Demers is coming so I won't kill you." He mumbles and I nod in agreement.

"I'll take a shower and then text you two." I say and he nods before he leaves. I take a long shower before I put on a sweatshirt and sweatpants. I text them to come and within a few minutes they're in my room. Jamie and I each sit on a couch with Demers sitting at the chair at the head of us.

"Who knows?" Jamie asks as he looks into my eyes still fuming

"Just you and Cassidy and now Demers." I say

"Well Jordie is going to find out so that he can kick your ass in the All Star Game."

"Fair." I sigh, "Do you want to know what happened?" I ask as I look up

"Yes." He nods

"Well you went out with Clarissa." I start, "Susannah and I decided to play beer bong and we got very drunk. I- dude. I can't lie. I'm in love with her. She likes me too. We just got drunk, and we explained it while we were drunk. We've had a few conversations about it she just doesn't want you to get mad at me." I say

"Yeah I'll talk to her about that." He laughs annoyed

"How about we wait for tomorrow morning to talk about it? Susannah can defend what she thinks and say what happened. I don't want either of you getting an idea in your head." Demers said. He was always level headed and I appreciated that.

"Deal. I'm calling Jordie though." Jamie said as he got up.

"Put him on speaker phone. I'll handle it." I sigh and Jamie looks at me with an eyebrow raised

"Finally responsible?" He laughs and I nod rolling my eyes.

"Hey. Why are you calling me this late?" Jordie groans as he answers the call from Jamie.

"Hey it's Tyler, um I just needed to talk to you." I say slowly trying to figure out how I'm going to tell him. He was very protective over Susannah and I knew he'd want to kill me.

"What about?" He asks as I can hear him sitting up.

"I- Susannah and I both like each other." I say