He's Not the Same (Black Hat x Reader)

Chapter 18

Previously

He just stared at me, sighing, "I just-"

"NO!! CUT YOUR 'KEEP YOU SAFE' BULLSHIT AND LISTEN TO ME!!" I yelled, teleporting inside of the chamber and wrapping my arms around his slender form.

"I love you, Black Hat..! And I always will!! I refuse to give up on you" Staring down at me, he sighed.

"Well... that escalated quickly, didn't it..?"

I stuck my tongue out at him, making his frown to slightly tilt upwards.

Continued

We both just stood there for a few seconds before embracing each other tightly.

I sniffled, choking back a sob as he rubbed my back comfortingly, his breathing beginning to grow heavier as tears of his own began to build up in his eye.

"I... I am so... so sorry, Black Hat..." I whispered, instantly making him pull away with his eye widened.

"W-WHAT?! YOU... You aren't the one who should be apologizing..! If anything, I should be the one to say SORRY!! I... I hurt you-"

"And I hurt YOU, Black Hat, I should have given you space and let you be" He sighed as a response, his gaze turning to the steel floor.

"Mi amor..?"

"Yes?"

"That wasn't the problem..." He mumbled, his eye flickering as he glanced at me.

I quickly took a step back, sucking in my breath as I got into a fighting stance, which Black Hat quickly noticed and looked at me with a frown.

"You're afraid of me..." My fists unclenched and fell to my sides, my expression softening to a sad glare.

"No... Black Hat, that wasn't you-"

"YES IT WAS!!!" I flinched, watching as his chest heaved up and down in... anger.

"YOU JUST WON'T LISTEN TO ME, (Y/N)!! I WANT TO PROTECT YOU-"

"NO, YOU WANT ME TO LEAVE!!!"  I screamed back, causing him to go into a full rage...

"BECAUSE IT'S THE ONLY WAY, DAMNIT!!! I LOVE YOU-NO, I CRAVE YOU, (Y/N)!! EVERYTIME ANYONE LOOKS AT YOU SIDEWAYS, OR WINKS, OR JUST... ANYTHING!!! MY BLOOD BOILS!!!! WE NEED TO STAY AWAY FROM EACHOTHER IN ORDER FOR EVERYONE TO REMAIN SAFE!!!! ISN'T THAT WHAT YOU WANT?!"

"NO!! I mean-YES!! BUT I WANT YOU TO BE-"

"THEN LEAVE AND DONT EVER COME BACK!!!"

I went silent, staring at him with fury, that soon disappeared and slowly turned into sadness and... heartbreak.

My eyes became glossy once more, tears beginning to build up, but I swiftly wiped them away with my hand. Looking away from him, I let out a quiet sob, but as much as I didn't want him to... he noticed.

"(Y-Y/n)... I-I didn't mean it like that, I-"

"It doesn't matter... I'm sorry for being such a burden..." Whispering, I teleported out of the cell, swiftly unlocking the steel door and running out the lab doors.

Instantly, I went into the living room, sobbing, instantly grabbing the attention of the other males.

The seven males ran towards me, immediately questioning me of what had just happened, but their eyes were then dragged to another figure that ran into the room.

As soon as I saw Black Hat, I grabbed my uncles and Laughing Jack with my tendrils and teleported back to the Creepypasta mansion.

---Black Hat's POV---

Just as my fingertips brushed against her shoulder, she teleported away...

"No..." I whispered, falling to my knees as Cipher and Thesis approached me cautiously.

"Black Hat..? Is that really you..??" I didn't say anything, just nodded slightly in response.

I brought my hand up to my face, staring at it as my other hand slid it off my finger.

The other two watched, their eyes wide as I lazily tossed it across the floor.

I couldn't hold it back any longer.

Leaning forward, I broke into a sob, my hands covering my face in anger and sorrow.

"DAAAAAAAAMNIIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!!!" I yelled, hitting the ground with my fists.

My claws dug into the wood floor as I choked back my tears, but they just kept flowing

Thesis and Cipher glanced at each other before sighing, both heading in opposite directions.

While Bill grabbed the black wedding ring, Thesis walked into another room, soon coming back with a limp Dr. Flug. He tossed the unconscious human onto the couch, and Cipher simply set it on the nightstand and snapped his fingers.

By then, I stopped paying attention, my eye dragging back to the floor.

'I'm sorry, mi amor... it was just too much for me to handle, first you go into a coma, then I go crazier and hurt you, now... this... please, forgive me...'

I wish I could have done better...

Maybe if I had just told her what was going on... this story would have had a different outcome..!

But no

I didn't do that

---Your POV---

I sobbed into Splendor's shoulder, hiccupping every now and then, while my father yelled.

"I KNEW IT!! I TOLD YOU HE WAS BAD FOR YOU!!!! BUT NO, YOU DIDN'T LISTEN TO ME, DID YOU?!?!"  He yelled, his face ripped to form a mouth.

"Slender..." Offenderman mumbled, then turning as father growled at him.

'Go easy on the child, she-'

"BE QUIET!! I AM HER FATHER, NOT YOU, YOU, OR YOU!!" Father interrupted Trendorman, then pointed at each of my uncles accusingly, then at, well, me...

"I AM NOT JUST GOING TO ALLOW YOU TO COME BACK HERE EVERY SINGLE TIME YOU ARE UPSET!!!" We stared at him, our 'eyes' wide as he yelled-

"GET OUT!!"