Eyes Don't Lie ✩ Jenna Ortega (G!P)

XL

| Y/N's POV |

"So she's given you blowjobs before and that was it? Besides the flirting." I clarified with Jenna who finally had the chance to take a day out of her busy schedule and spend some time with me.

She sighed shamefully, burying her face in my chest. "Yep... I am ashamed of that, but it's the truth." Jenna lifted her head up to look at me. "I just thought you should hear it from me and not her if you ever come visit me on set. 'Cause then she'll screw my words up and fuck up our relationship."

I rubbed the back of her neck, wrapping my legs around her waist since she was laying on top of me. "Thank you for telling me."

Jenna sighed. "I really don't want to ruin what we have."

"I know." I cooed as I kissed her forehead. "It wouldn't be your fault if she spread lies like that. You told me the truth and that's all that matters." I held her face in my hands. "Now, can we go on a date?"

"Absolutely." Jenna smiled and lifted herself off of me, holding her hand out for me that I happily took. "Where were you thinking?"

"Surprise me."

—————

"We're here." I removed the blindfold that Jenna had me put on. I looked back and gasped excitedly when I saw the arcade we parked in front of. "Ready?"

"Hell yeah!" I laughed and got out the car after Jenna opened the door for me, my hand excitedly grabbing hers in mine. "I'm gonna kick your ass in basketball."

"That's what you think." Jenna scoffed and we looked at each other before sprinting towards the arcade doors, trying to see who will get there first. I ended up winning and Jenna wrapped her arms around me from behind, lifting me up for a split second that sent me into a giggling frenzy.

We walked inside and bought a few tokens. The thing we liked about this arcade was that it was old school. It didn't depend on technology - like buying online cards or stuff like that to play these games - here we get real tickets and play with tokens. Kinda like old school Chuck E. Cheese.

Jenna took my hand and we immediately wandered over to the basketball courts. We had to shoot as many balls into the hoop in a limited amount of time.

"Ready?" Jenna slide a few tokens in, hitting her start button.

"Hell yeah." I did the same and we were immediately battling head to head. Jenna had better form than I did but I was much faster in grabbing the balls. All in all, the score was 37-35 with me in the lead. "Take that!"

"I'll buy you a prize." Jenna looked at me with a smile. "What do you want?"

"I know a prize that I want... and it's free." I wrapped my arms around her neck.

"You're speaking my language." She chuckled and gave me what I wanted, leaning down as she placed her lips on mine in a searing kiss. "Mm, I love that."

"Yeah? I bet." I smirked and dragged her away again to the claw machines. We played games back and forth for about an hour before we went to the prize counter. Jenna bought a stuffed panda for me and I got her a little throw blanket.

We were walking out with our prizes, Jenna's arm wrapped around my waist, her hand slightly on my ass. I looked at her and then behind her to see a group of college guys staring at us. They must've been looking at me, Jenna noticed, and got jealous so that's why her hand is on my ass.

If still wasn't enough and I didn't want her to know that so I gently grabbed her face, turning her towards me as I leaned up to softly kiss her again. All of her jealousy faded away as she melted into the kiss, holding my torso to pull me closer.

"Let's go home, yeah? Can you stay the night?" I asked in a whisper.

"I'll do anything for you." Jenna mumbled back which made me smile as we both got in her car.

When we got to my apartment, I dropped our prizes off on the table, following Jenna upstairs where immediately lifted her shirt off her head, discarding the pants that she was wearing.

"Cuddles. Please." She laid on my bed, spread out like a starfish with her arms wide open for me. I giggled and threw my shirt aside too, jumping into her arms.

I rested my head against her chest. The soft thud of her heart comforted me and before I knew it, I was falling asleep in my girlfriend's arms.

—————

| Jenna's POV |

"Yeah... I don't know what to do." I pinched the bridge of my nose in frustration. I was on the phone with Emma and I've been in the bathroom for a little bit now, somehow managing to slip out from under Y/N and her cute, clingy grip. "I haven't told her yet because one; I don't know who it's from and two; I don't need her worrying about that right now. She's getting ready to release an album soon and a new clothing line."

I sat on top of the toilet seat with a sigh. "I can't ruin that for her with my problems."

"Jen, your problems are her problems. Y/N is going to want to solve this with you, she wouldn't want you dealing with it alone. Especially since you know she has your back no matter what." Emma pointed out. "Trust her with it, okay? Who knows? Maybe she'll know something."

"Maybe." I thought for a moment. "Thanks, Em. I hope to see you soon."

"Oh you will, don't forget about season two of Wednesday, girl. We're getting back into action next year."

"Can't wait." I laughed in agreement before hanging up. I didn't want to burden Y/N with this, but Emma was right.

~
A/N:
can't believe ima Junior in hs already...
and how much do y'all love this book?