Eyes Don't Lie ✩ Jenna Ortega (G!P)

LIV

| Olivia's POV |

"So, what do you wanna do?" I walked out of Billie's bathroom wearing her clothes. I put mine away in a bag, seeing her smiling down at her phone. "Billie."

"Yeah?" She responded mindlessly, chuckling as she bit down on her lip, still staring at her phone.

"What do you wanna do?" She looked up at me and set her phone down, crossing her arms.

"I'm not sure, you?" I took a seat beside her on her bed. Billie's phone suddenly went off like a million times, receiving a shit ton of messages. "Who's texting you?"

"Oh." Billie paused before sneaking a peak at her phone. "Just this girl I'm gonna see tomorrow."

"Who?" I don't know why I felt jealous but I did.

"I don't know, she's just a hookup." Billie muttered, opening her phone again.

"Okay... so what are we?" She looked up at me with confusion written on her face. "Like, what're we doing? Hooking up? What?"

"Liv, we're just friends who, I don't know, have sex every once in a while." Billie shrugged her shoulders so casually. It almost pissed me off.

"So we're friends with benefits? While you see other people?" I asked again, gesturing with my hands.

"Yep." Billie popped the 'p', continuing to stare at her phone.

"Okay." I huffed and stood up, grabbing my belongings and putting my shoes back on. Billie glanced up at me.

"Woah, woah. Where you going?" She sat up and followed me out of her bedroom downstairs to her living room. "Liv!"

"I'm just your friend, remember? Have fun with the other girls in your phone or whatever." I growled and slammed the door behind me.

"Liv!" The door was immediately thrown back open by Billie who stood on her porch, watching me walk away. "How are you gonna get home?! It's almost midnight and you don't have a ride!"

"I'll be fine, leave me alone!" It was stupid to say but I'd rather take my chances in the dark than have to handle a car ride with her where she might try seducing me to make me forget about everything that just happened.

This is why I stick to men. The heartbreak sucks but with women? God, it's like someone stomped on my heart a million times over.

—————

| Y/N's POV |

I am gonna be so hung over tomorrow.

I crashed in bed, waiting for Jenna to get out of the shower. I heard the doorbell ring from downstairs, making me shoot up into a sitting position. I looked at the bathroom door before slipping a robe on, walking downstairs.

I glanced through the peephole and immediately opened the door. "Livie? What's wrong? It's midnight, are you okay?"

"No." She sniffled. Liv was a mess. She had mascara running down her face from all the obvious crying she did. Her eyes were filled with such sadness, it broke my heart. "Can I crash here? Please?"

"Of course, of course. Come here, sweetie." I welcomed her into my arms, kicking the door closed as Liv began sobbing in my arms.

"I hate that I fell for her." She cried out into my shoulder. The mention of a 'her' almost made my heart skip a beat but it seemed like Liv was incredibly hurt by this girl. I'd like to kill whoever it is that hurt my Livie. "I hate love."

I let my best friend cry out anything she wanted and when she was done, I helped guide Liv upstairs. Jenna was leaning against the door frame with her towel wrapped around her waist, looking at us with a look of understanding in her eyes.

Jenna pushed open the door to the guest bedroom where I proceeded to help Liv get ready for bed. The clothes she was wearing were almost familiar, like I've seen them before but I chose to ignore it.

I tucked her in, pulling the blanket over her fragile body. "I'm right across the hall if you need me." I kissed Liv's cheek before flipping the light off, walking out of the room.

When I reached my bedroom, I looked at Jenna who was sitting on the bed, waiting to me. "She okay?"

"I hope so." I sat down with a sigh, feeling her arms wrap around my body. "She seemed so heartbroken, it almost killed me."

"I wonder what happened." Jenna hummed as she ran her fingers through my hair.

"Me too." I sighed again. "One thing is for sure, I hate the person who broke her heart. Whoever they are."

~
A/N:
Oop- hi 🥰