Creepypasta Oneshots (Completed)

Romeo and Juliet Part Two (Ticci Toby x Zalgo's!daughter!reader)

Hey @PurpleViola ! I liked this idea for this oneshot but it was too long, so, I split it into two parts.

I hope that's okay.

Thanks for the cool request again.
______________________________________

Y/n's POV:
I hummed to myself as I brushed my hair out, sitting at my dressing table.

Me and Toby have been dating for eight months now, and it's been getting harder and harder to keep it hidden.

Toby couldn't think about me at all around Slender, which is kind of hard.

I sighed as I put my brush down and looked at my reflection.

"Y/n?"

I jumped as a strangled sound of surprise escaped my throat.

I turned around in my chair to see my dad, Zalgo, standing by my now open bedroom door, arms crossed over his chest as he stared at with a raised eyebrow.

"You okay?" He questioned as he walked over to me.

I gulped as I slowly nodded my head.

"Of course, dad. Why wouldn't I be okay?" I hurriedly questioned.

He stopped infront of me and crouched down so our eyes were locked. E/c locking with red.

He shrugged,"You've seemed off these last few months. Like, you're giddy but nervous as well. I'm just curious."

'Shit!' I screamed internally as I had an internal panick attack while my composure on the outside was calm and collected.

"I have? I haven't noticed." I shrugged as I bit my tongue.

He slowly nodded before standing up.

"Well, alright than. Put your battle gear on. It's time." He spoke as he dusted his suit off.

"Time?" I questioned as I tilted my head in confusion.

He nodded,"Time for the battle you've been preparing for. Now, suit up."

My eyes widened as my jaw went slack.

Me and Toby.... along with a few others... we'll be fighting to the death.

Zalgo silently left while I sat in my chair. I hastily grabbed my phone and dialed Toby's number.

I brought my phone to me ear, pacing up and down the room as I bit into my nail on my finger.

"Come on Toby. Pick up." I mumbled nervously.

The phone stopped ringing before Toby's voice spoke through the phone.

"Y/n?"

I breathed our in relief,"Toby..."

"I'-m guess-ing you hea-rd about to-day.." he nervously breathed out.

I hummed,"Yeah...."

"What-'re we gon-na do, N/n?" He softly and wearily questioned.

I sighed as I moved to sit on my bed. I hung my head as I rubbed my temple.

"I don't know, dear. I'm scared." I confessed.

"Hey, he-y. D- on't be afra-id. Let's just le-t natu-re tak-e its cou-rse." Toby explained.

"But, what if... what if we... we have-"

"T-o kill som-eone?" He cut me off.

"Yeah..." I breathed out.

Silence.

I knew Toby was afraid as well. I mean, all his friends and Slender would be there.

Who wouldn't be afraid if you'd have to kill your girlfriend infront of them?