Fatal Flaw
ForgivenAtTheCross
  • Reads 55,049
  • Votes 3,067
  • Parts 60
  • Time 2h 31m
  • Reads 55,049
  • Votes 3,067
  • Parts 60
  • Time 2h 31m
ForgivenAtTheCross
Complete, First published Aug 23, 2014
christianitychristineerikerikxchristineeristinefanfictionfatalflawfeelsfluffoperaghostphanfictionphantompheelsphluffpoto
On the night the Opera Populaire was consumed by fire, Erik rode into the wilderness on horseback, discovering an expansive castle that... 
Belonged to him? 

He lived there, all alone... 
Until Christine happened to show up at his doorstep. 

But why was she there? 
Where was Raoul?
What if Erik and Christine both had... 
A fatal flaw?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Other Information:
• In introducing Erik to Christianity in this fanfiction, I do not mean to play the part of God. "Fatal Flaw" is just a fictional story, and I really wanted to see Erik find the Light. In real life, however, only the Lord can make this happen.

• The characters in this story belong to their rightful owners (such as Gaston Leroux and Victor Hugo), not to me. All I've done is taken them and written a fanfiction about them.
All Rights Reserved
christianitychristineerikerikxchristineeristinefanfictionfatalflawfeelsfluffoperaghostphanfictionphantompheelsphluffpoto
Table of contents

60 parts

Sign up to add Fatal Flaw to your library and receive updates
or
#127phanfiction
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera by SimpleSav
29 parts Complete
"Christine, I love you." The phantom's voice played a sweet tune in my mind. It was the first time he had confessed his love, but sadly, I couldn't return the favor. He had given me everything, fame, fortune, and a life of excitement and curiosity. Still, he had threatened to hang my beloved Raoul and sentence me to an eternity locked away from the world. My clammy hands shook with emotion as I slid the beautiful, diamond ring off my finger. The disfigured man helplessly gazed into my eyes, transforming my soul. I was the only one to look past his hideous physical appearance, to know how to comfort a creature of darkness; I couldn't bare holding in my emotions any longer. Tears plunged down my pale cheeks and I looked down to take his hand. Making sure not to drop the small item, I closed his rough fingers around the ring. "Goodbye," all sadness echoing through my word. I spun around and dragged my wedding dress through the foggy water to meet Raoul's awaiting boat. *** UPDATE 2020: Hello, all! I realized that this book recently gained traction in the fanfic world of Wattpad, again. Unfortunately, I wrote this back in 2014 and have yet to go through and edit. At one point, I planned on making a sequel to this. I don't expect to do so any time soon, but I appreciate the reads and the comments!
Christine, That's all I ask of you by _another_phangirl
21 parts Complete
{Follows the 2004 film} Christine got married to Raoul and they seemed to be happy together. But in a few months Christine realized that maybe something was wrong. Raoul cheated on her. She thought that maybe she made a wrong choice and continued thinking of Erik... Her poor unhappy Erik. Is he still down there? Is he even alive? (I'm so sorry for some errors, I'm not English actually. Thanks for understanding)
The Phantom Ascending |✔| [Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction] by olivesky
68 parts Complete
Christine left and the Phantom of the Opera sank into despair. Yet when he discovers something magical in Cornwall, it will set him on the road toward Christine again. And she now resides in Venice, the city of gondolas, carnivals and mists... A tale of anguish, heartbreak, hope and love; of obsession and redemption. The story of the Phantom of the Opera continues, and the everlasting emotions unravel once again. Act I -- A short story about Erik after the final lair Act II -- A brief insight into Christine's time with Raoul Act III, IV & V -- Main plot unravels and new mysteries arise. Packed with romance and all the feels. -- Cover by the wonderful @Juliette_Aurora :) -- The Phantom of the Opera (2004) fanfiction, set after the final lair scene, and best enjoyed after you've watched the movie or the stage musical. -- The Phantom of the Opera was originally created by Gaston Leroux, and the musical adaptation belongs to Lloyd Webber/Hart/Stilgoe. All concepts and characters belong to their respective owners, and this work is nonprofit. It's intended for entertainment and wish fulfillment only, not being a part of the official storyline.
Your Music Fills My Soul {Erik Destler x Reader} by purple_glass_hearts
26 parts Complete Mature
The Vicomte and Vicomtesse de Chagny have come to visit the Opera Populaire for the first time. Little did they know that the moment they stepped into that opera house, their lives would change from then on. ♡ I hope you enjoy this book. Please feel free to comment. I am completely fine with critiques or any. I apologize if I have made any grammatic errors. All songs used in this book have been written and the end of the chapter. All Phantom of the Opera songs are by Andrew Lloyd Webber. I only own this book and the characters I have created. This book is mainly based from the Phantom of the Opera musical and the 2004 movie. There are slight references to the book but I unfortunately didn't make many since I don't know alot about the book. ♡ Started Writing Book: Nov. 2, 2023 (Part 1) Completed: Nov. 19, 2023 (Part 2) Started: Nov. 20, 2023 Completed: Dec. 10, 2023 (might be made. we'll see :3 ↓) (Part 3) Started: - Completed: - Finished Editing: May 5, 2024 Published: May 5, 2024 ♡ May 5, 2024: Oh my god- I finally published it- *freaking out*
Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera by nerdywriter36
37 parts Complete
Christine is dead and the Phantom is alone once more. But this time...not completely. He now has Gustave, their child, with him. After learning the truth, he is determined to stay with his true father. Though talented in many areas, will fatherhood be the one skill Erik cannot master? A collab with my awesome IRL friend @Buddy_2002! Gif banner and cover by the amazing @BrendaDaaeDestler! Winner of Best General Phanfic and Best Summary in The Phantom's Rose Awards hosted by @BrendaDaaeDestler! Cover also by @BrendaDaaeDestler <3 Elements pulled from both 'Phantom of the Opera' as well as 'Love Never Dies', written by Andrew Lloyd Webber, with heavy influence from 'Phantom' by Susan Kay
The Phantom's Butterfly by Duds_003
17 parts Ongoing Mature
Sophia was a perfect girl with an ideal family. She has a perfect life with her wealthy parents and talented people. Suddenly, she died in a car crash. But she was transmigrated from her favorite R-19 erotic romance novel 'The Phantasma' and reincarnated as Angelica Rodriguez, the noble daughter of Marquess Rodriguez and the most beautiful woman in her country of England, and a side character who was fated to die in the chandelier accident caused by the Phantom's anger, the antagonist in the story. To prevent her death in the future, she must change the Phantom's fate and then make the female protagonist fall in love with the Phantom so that she can live an undisturbed life, but... That wasn't according to her plan. "I love you, Angelica," he murmured, his breath a ghost against my skin as he clutched my hands with a grip that bordered on pain. "I've loved you with an all-consuming fire since our youth. My soul has bound to yours. You are the light that pierces my eternal night. Should anyone dare to harm you, to seduce you... I will unleash a fury so consuming it will erase them from existence. I will tear them apart piece by piece." His grip tightened further, his eyes alight with a ferocious, almost unhinged devotion. Then she realized... She became his new obsession. Will she continue her plan and live a peaceful life? Or will she accept and fall in love instead? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Note: Chapters 0 to 9 are currently under revision. I'm trying to enhance the narrative and character development to provide a richer reading experience. Thank you for your understanding and support as I refine this journey. Stay tuned for the updated chapters!
Don't give up on me. by Coolkoala547
13 parts Ongoing
10 years later and now under the disguise of Mr. Y Erik destler begins his plan for a triumphant return, but not as you'd expect, Erik builds his own opera populair from the ground up with the help of the giry's, his opera house becomes an instant success but to him, it's been a complete failure because the one woman he longs to be reunited with hasn't seen him in 10 years, but what happens when he makes an offer she can't refuse, what choice will Christine make this time and does love really never die? NOTE: I OWN NONE OF THESE CHARACTERS
Hunter in the Dark by Rose-de-Noire
4 parts Complete Mature
Raoul's older sibling returns to Paris and is instantly fascinated by the Phantom, Erik in turn is just annoyed to have one more de Chagny in the picture. So they go for a hunt, each with their own motives. It turns out differently as each of them expected. This story begins at the end, kinda. ------------------ This is an older story of mine I overhauled and therefore already finished! Rating: NC-17 hetero Genre: Romance Pairing: E/OC Words: around 10'000 Status: Complete Warnings: Wild mix of all the phantom-verses, mainly Kay and definitely AU A lot of OOC'ness from Raoul's and Philippe's part (even if we never see him in persona). The Persian too and Erik... Oh heck, Erik... Erik is just my version Erik. Means, he's a medley of all the Eriks/Phantoms I know in literature, films, musicals mixed with a good brush of my own dirty, insane, phantasies and memories. But, he always looks like Leroux/Kay Erik, only his eyes just reflect in the dusty light of darkness and seem to be yellow-cattish; in peaceful daylight they're from the color like of the midnight-sky, with golden sparkles, like falling stardust... With this I bid you goodbye and let you read...
Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || by Phantom_Christine_5
23 parts Complete
One event changed everything in Christine Daae's life. Erik Destlar fell in love with her and decided to take her to live with him. Will she ever love him back? Modern day, E/C... COMPLETED ___________________________________________________________ I do NOT claim the original work of Gaston Leroux "The Phantom of the Opera." I also do NOT condone things discussed, written, or otherwise made known through my work such as stalking, kidnapping, marrying kidnappers/stalkers, or the like. My only wish is to make Leroux's book accessible to modern readers with a few plot twists here and there. I can only hope I have done his acclaimed work justice with my retelling.
Love Is A Battle(Sequel to A Fallen Rose Behind a Hidden Mask) by VampireWarrior101
19 parts Complete
t has been ten year since the tragedy of the opera house, the "tragedy" of Erik and Angelique. Christine and Raoul are married and have their own son named Gustav. Erik and Angelique are married as well and have two sons and two daughters. Erik and Angelique have started a circus in Phantasma and they couldn't be happier with their new family there. But...unfortunately....an enemy from Angelique's past....a brother who is alive and seek revenge for Raoul....a bother by the name of Victor....what happens when Angelique and Erik find out he is alive? Will he be a threat? Also, what will happen when Raoul and Christine fin out that Angelique and Erik are alive? Will there be love? Hatred?....A battle for love?
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera cover
Christine, That's all I ask of you cover
The Phantom Ascending |✔| [Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction] cover
Your Music Fills My Soul {Erik Destler x Reader} cover
Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera cover
The Phantom's Butterfly cover
Don't give up on me. cover
Hunter in the Dark cover
Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || cover
Love Is A Battle(Sequel to A Fallen Rose Behind a Hidden Mask) cover

Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera

29 parts Complete

"Christine, I love you." The phantom's voice played a sweet tune in my mind. It was the first time he had confessed his love, but sadly, I couldn't return the favor. He had given me everything, fame, fortune, and a life of excitement and curiosity. Still, he had threatened to hang my beloved Raoul and sentence me to an eternity locked away from the world. My clammy hands shook with emotion as I slid the beautiful, diamond ring off my finger. The disfigured man helplessly gazed into my eyes, transforming my soul. I was the only one to look past his hideous physical appearance, to know how to comfort a creature of darkness; I couldn't bare holding in my emotions any longer. Tears plunged down my pale cheeks and I looked down to take his hand. Making sure not to drop the small item, I closed his rough fingers around the ring. "Goodbye," all sadness echoing through my word. I spun around and dragged my wedding dress through the foggy water to meet Raoul's awaiting boat. *** UPDATE 2020: Hello, all! I realized that this book recently gained traction in the fanfic world of Wattpad, again. Unfortunately, I wrote this back in 2014 and have yet to go through and edit. At one point, I planned on making a sequel to this. I don't expect to do so any time soon, but I appreciate the reads and the comments!

More details