*Maddy's POV*
The door knocked. I was in my pajamas and my hair wasn't even done. I slowly walked to the door and opened it.
My boyfriend Hayes stood their with flowers and a couple of movies. "Happy three months."
I ran up to him and gave him a tight hug. "You're adorable."
"I try, babe." Hayes giggled and kissed me on the cheek. "I have The Notebook and the Last Song. Which one do you wanna watch first?"
"Those are my favorites," I giggled. "I guess The Notebook. Shoot I just realized that our new TV is coming in tomorrow. Is it okay if we watch it at your house?"
"Yeah, that's fine." Hayes took my hand as we walked to his house. Hayes lives down the street from me, so we get to see each other a lot.
Hayes opened the door and his brother Nash walked into the hallway, shirtless.
"Oh, hey Maddy." Nash said.
I rolled my eyes. "Hey, put on a shirt."
Nash and I are really close. Almost like brother and sister.
Hayes and I went downstairs in the basement and got the movie ready.
"I have to go to the bathroom. I'll be right back." I said, and went upstairs.
After I went to the bathroom, someone grabbed my wrist. I spun around, it was Nash.
"Can I help you?" I giggled.
Nash pulled me in closer to him. What is going on?
"You look really pretty today." Nash smiled.
"Thanks...Nash." I smiled slightly. Was Nash flirting with me? There's no way. I thought we had a brother-sister relationship.
Nash pulled me even closer and put his arms around my waist. "How about we don't tell Hayes about this?"
"A-about what?"
"Us."
Nash tried to kiss me but I tried pulling away. He pulled me back in and kissed me this time. And we kissed for a really long time. I couldn't pull away. Nash kept holding me to him.
I finally pulled away and pushed Nash. "What were you thinking!"
"I don't know. I, uh, kissed you for a reason." Nash scratched his neck.
"And what is that reason?" I crossed me arms. I'm furious. If Hayes saw that, he would be devastated. His own brother kissing me on our 3 month anniversary.
"Because I find you hot." Nash smirked.
"No, no, no. This cannot be happening." I started to panic.
"Relax."
"Why should I relax!"
"I know how to get you to relax." Nash took my hand and brought me upstairs. He pinned me down and kissed me. I couldn't get away and escape. We ended up making out for a really long time. Like ten minutes. I sort of enjoyed it in a way, but felt really guilty. I grabbed Nash's shirt and started to take it off. I don't know why. We continued making out until we heard the door burst open.
"What the hell is going on!" Screamed Hayes, tears were flowing down his face.
"H-Hayes," I got up. "I can explain."
"You freaking cheated on me on our anniversary. And with my brother!" Hayes was crying really hard now. I started to cry too.
"I tried to get away but.." I trailed off.
"I watched for a little and you seemed to enjoy making out with my brother." Hayes yelled.
"Hayes, calm down." Nash said.
"Shut up and put your freaking shirt on!" Hayes yelled. "You had me waiting in the basement for fifteen minutes."
"I-I'm so sorry, Hayes." I cried.
"You...slut. You slut! Get out of my freaking house! We're through!" Hayes screamed. I started to walk out, but Nash grabbed my wrist.
"No, she's staying." Nash said, still holding on to me.
"Oh really? Just so you two can keep making out? Okay, yeah, that's totally fine. Go ahead. Have fun." Hayes cried.
"Hayes, stop. I'm sorry I dragged her into this. I just...really like her and she, uh, seemed to really enjoy it." Nash said.
"How could you even have the nerve to say that."
"Because it's true. She took my shirt off and everything_"
"Nash, shut up! Maddy, get out of my house!" Hayes yelled.
I ran out with mixed feelings. I loved Hayes, but at the same time, I loved kissing Nash, and I felt something between us. I felt guilty. I ran home, crying my eyes out. Which Grier is the one for me?
