Fixer Review Shop [OPEN]

~ Review 68 - Anatomy of the Heart by SubhankiIndia ~

Book Information

Title: Anatomy of the Heart
Author/Poet: SubhankiIndia
Genre: Poetry
Chapters: 18

Reviewed by Sharon_nthelse

Plot Development:
• Generally minimal: Focus tends to be on moments, emotions, or ideas. Narrative elements, when present (friend encounter, past reflection), show a progression, often internal.

• Potential Corrections: For narrative-leaning poems, consider strengthening the sense of cause and effect or the unfolding of events to create a more defined "plot," even if it's subtle.

Character Depth:
• Emotional states and perspectives are often revealed. Depth varies; some speakers are well-realized, others serve as voices for feelings. The "you" can be ambiguous.

• Potential Corrections: Where "characters" (even implied) exist, consider adding specific details (internal thoughts, motivations, subtle actions) to create a more profound sense of depth and believability. For ambiguous "you" figures, decide if the ambiguity is intentional and effective, or if a subtle hint could enhance understanding.

Writing Style:
• Direct emotional expression, sometimes sparse imagery. Tone varies. Experimentation with line breaks and stanzas, but rhyme can be inconsistent.

• Potential Corrections:
    • Imagery: Consistently layer more vivid and sensory details to enhance the reader's experience. Extend metaphors and connect them to larger frameworks.
    • Tone: Ensure the tone is consistent and effectively supports the poem's emotional core.
    • Rhythm and Musicality: Pay closer attention to word choice, sentence structure, and line breaks to create a more deliberate and pleasing rhythm when read aloud. Vary sentence length and structure.

Originality:
• Original perspectives (scar speaking), central metaphors (waiting hearts, birds), and explored scenarios (sacrifice burden) are present. Exploration of complex emotions is also unique.

• No General Correction Needed (Strength to Maintain): Continue to cultivate these unique perspectives and explore unconventional ideas and emotions.

Grammar:
• Consistently correct.

• No Correction Needed (Strength to Maintain): Maintain this accuracy.

Emotional Impact:
• A significant strength. Poems frequently evoke strong emotions (empathy, sadness, unease, anger, longing).

• Potential Correction: Explore the nuances within these strong emotions to add further depth. Show the reasons behind the feelings and the subtle shifts within them.

Overall Coherence:
• Varies. Some poems have clear centrals ideas with unified elements. Others with abstract imagery or fragmented narratives can lacks clear connections.

• Potential Corrections:
    • Clarity of Connections: Ensure logical and thematic links between lines and stanzas are evident to the reader. Use transition words or phrases if necessary.
    • Unified Impact: Review each poem to ensure all elements (imagery, tone, structure) work together to create a single, powerful effect.

General Guidance for Moving Forward:
• Focus on Sensory Details: Engage more of the reader's senses (sight, sound, smell, tough, taste) in your descriptions.

• Show, Don't Tell: Instead of stating an emotion, illustrate it through action, imagery, and dialogue (whet applicable).

• Refine Line Breaks and Pacing: Experiment with line breaks to control the rhythm and emphasize key words or phrases. Vary the pace to build tension or create a sense of reflection.

• Explore Figurative Language Deliberately: Use similes, metaphors, and symbolism intentionally to add layers of meaning and create stronger connections with the reader.