Amaryllis | REVIEW SHOP [ CLOSED ]

《Pooja》Cotton Popps

Client: S_R_Patra

Reviewer: Just_Me_Pooja

Cover - 4/10

The current cover is simplistic and focuses solely on cotton pops, which might mislead potential readers about the genre. A redesign is essential to convey the detective story element more prominently, ensuring it attracts the right audience seeking mystery content.

Title - 5/10

While the current title is cute, it may not effectively communicate the mystery genre. Consider an improvised title that incorporates mystery elements, offering potential readers a clearer indication of the story's genre and enticing those specifically interested in detective narratives.

Description - 6/10

While the description is limited, it holds essential information. However, it could benefit from expansion to provide potential readers with a more detailed glimpse into the story. Adding a bit more intrigue or key plot points could make it more compelling and increase its effectiveness in attracting the right audience for the detective narrative.

Vocabulary and Grammar - 12/20

While the English exhibits an enhanced vocabulary, there are noticeable grammar mistakes within the text. For instance, the phrase "He was a white man in his forty" could be refined for clarity. If referring to his color, alternatives like "fair" or "light-skinned" could be more precise. If nationality is intended, specifying "English" or another nationality would be clearer. Similarly, "it was a chubby cat" could be improved with a more descriptive term like "plump." Addressing these nuances will contribute to a more polished and precise narrative.

Plot - 8/10

The plot is a breath of fresh air, introducing a new and original detective story. With its unique elements, it captures the reader's attention, promising an intriguing narrative. However, the limitation of one chapter leaves little room for significant twists, and the potential in this regard remains untapped.

Twist - 0/10

Given the confined space of just one chapter, the narrative lacks the opportunity to introduce any twists. The absence of unexpected elements in the initial chapter may hinder the story's ability to surprise and captivate readers.

Enjoyment - 7/10

From a third-person perspective, the reader's enjoyment is apparent. The novel plot contributes to a satisfying reading experience, offering a unique narrative that resonates positively. As the story progresses, the potential for heightened enjoyment remains promising.

Total : 63/100