Until Dawn One Shots

Mike X Reader: Short Shot Caught Starin'

How can you not stare?^^ Come on... XD Isn't that just the best picture ever?

Requested by NerdyGirl1219 ! This is just for the giggles.. It isn't legitimate. It's a Short Shot... XD
_________________________
You arrive at Mike's apartment, as he had offered you to join him in watching a horror movie on HBO. It was one you were too afraid to watch on your own, so obviously you needed a comforting person there beside you. Mike'll work. ;)

You approached the apartment door, raising your fisted hand up to the door, knocking gently. He heard, coming up to open it, no sound behind him.

"Hey, (Y/N)!" He greeted cheerfully, allowing you to enter. You did so, immediately approaching the couch, taking a seat. The TV had been paused on the starting picture of two people conversing with each other, not yet hearable since it was paused, but you didn't mind. You'd rather wait for Mike, anyway.

"Are you sure you want to watch this?" He asked politely, keeping in mind that little fear you contained.

"Play it!" You demanded boldly, handing him the televisions remote.

"Okay?.." He took it, pressing on the black and white play button, sitting next to you.

You sat silently through the beginning, no supernatural events taking place in the first ten minutes like every usual horror movie would. But then they were, leaving you past scared straight, you typically begging Mike to take you in his grip.

You pushed yourself into his arms, them wrapping around you, pulling you closer. Your head gently was resting on his chest, the fear you once had, disappearing when you stared up to his face...

It was gorgeous...

You couldn't help yourself but to keep your eyes locked staring up at him, it mesmerizing you into some sort of other world. You grew silent, the movie just seeming to not be there at all. It didn't faze you any longer, obviously leaving Mike suspicious.

A jump scare occurred, you still remaining silent, not screaming like you had recently before. He stared down to you, taking you away from you little trance.

"Why aren't you scared?" He asked, removing his eyes from the screen, down to you. You immediately looked away, proceeding to watch.

"I got used to it, I guess." You said lying, flinching by one occurring just then when you happened to be watching. He looked to you, not believing it.

"Come on, (Y/N). Stop lying."

"What?" You asked, playing dumb. He doesn't know your lying. Just so he didn't know what you were doing prior, you refused to look at him.

"It was obvious you were staring at my beautiful face." He mocked, you then rolling your eyes.

You then begun to slowly look up to him, obviously slightly nervous. As you did see him better in view, you noticed him wiggling his eyebrows stupidly, causing you to laugh aloud.

"Mike, what the hell is wrong with you?" You laughed, beginning to tease him.

"I'm just speaking the truth." He shot back, smiling in the mix of laughing with you.

"Some of it was true." You said, your voice low.

"So you're saying I have a beautiful face?" He asked, teasing you still. You obviously just admitted that.

"Yes.. You have a beautiful fucking face, Mike." You said, going along with what he was going on about, still telling the truth you believed was actually not a lie.

"Lover girl."