Until Dawn One Shots

Mike X Reader X Josh: Which One

Requested by @TaylorFisher4!
________________________
You walked down the streets, conversing with Sam as you went along. You planned on meeting Josh, and Mike at a Coffee Shop on the corner, just to hang out, and catch up on a few things. You usually weren't comfortable around the two together with you, considering all they do is battle about you choosing one or the other. It ticked you off to an extent, you not enjoying their presence because of it. But, you felt that today would be a day to settle it, end this feud they continued on about. This may only make it worse, but you hoped for the best.

"So," Sam piped up, taking you away from you endless train of thought. "Who do ya think you're gonna choose?"

"Don't wanna think about it." You replied, sighing. "How is this gonna work out, anyway?" You asked, confused what your role was in all of this, besides being the obvious 'hard to get' girl.

"Well," she begun. "I'm thinking that you could like- separately talk with them? See who you prefer more?" She recommended, you agreeing to it.

"True." You agreed, nodding your head up and down. "Very organized. I like it."

"And I like your enthusiasm." Sam added, laughing weakly to your comment.

You just smiled to her, the Coffee Shop viewed ahead. You felt your stomach churn as you approached it, the guys already at a booth near the window, seeming to be getting along rather well. Laughing at whatever the other had to say, keeping your mood up high as you entered the front door, a bell sounding, alerting the whole Shop you were there.

Sam was the one to greet the boys, allowing you to just remain back, and take it all in. Prepare for whatever was in store for the near future.

"Hey guys." She waved hello, their attention coming to the both of you.

"Hey." Mike replied, shining a smile to both you, and Sam. Josh then said the same thing, it similar to how Mike had done it.

"Okay, so," Sam started, rubbing her hands together for warmth, "to the reason we came here. Let's address the little elephant between all of you, make this all clear. (Y/N), and I decided on a little way to settle your constant fighting over her, and it's fairly simple. You both will have a chance to have your 'words' with her, in all privacy. Whoever she prefers is the lucky one.. Got it?"

The boys nodded, not knowing what to say to that.

"And no fights.." She added, amused to their puzzled faces of all they have to take in. "Last thing we want."

The guys exchanged glances, then focusing back on you. They seemed to communicate through whatever they just did, one able to speak for both of them.

"We decided that I would go first." Mike explained, pushing his chair back, away from the table, allowing Sam to take his seat.

"You two stay here." You insisted, them nodding there heads. "Be back in about ten minutes."

You looked up to Mike, a smile curving your lips upward, you tempting to reach for his hand, and just hold it as you walked, but it was best not to. You didn't want him to just suppose he was the one already chosen. That was the last thing you want to worry about.

You both found a high table, both agreeing it be the one chosen. It was opposite from Sam, and Josh at the moment, them just speaking likewise about what would be happening between yourself, and Mike, or possibly Josh later on, and the extra bit of information not yet explained. At least that is what you believed.