I don't want to be your friend anymore

18| Day 1 {M} Pt. 2

He pulled her even closer to him, grabbed his dick and pointed it up towards her pussy. He rubbed it on her slit a couple of times, seeing the condom get slicked and shiny with her wetness. He grabbed her waist with his other hand and pulled her forward, making her slit split and glide up on his shaft. Jessica moaned when Eli then pushed her hips back, so he kept doing that and looking up at her until she looked down at him, her brows knitting together and her lips puckering out.

"Stop fucking teasing me" she whined.

"What you want me to do?" he asked.

"Make me cum" she immediately asserted.

She said it like it was the most obvious thing ever and Eli couldn't help the horny and proud smirk that etched on his lips.

Oh, this was going to be one hell of a ride!

"Sit" he commanded. He felt such a wave of pleasure from telling her what to do that he did it again. "Sit on me."

Jessica did just that. She slowly sat down, making the tip of his dick push against her entrance. When it went in, she gasped loudly. Eli's strong grunt made him feel the vibrations of his deep voice travelling through Jessica's chest cavity and hitting her back, where his hand was resting.

He literally felt the tip of his dick pop into her, like he had broken a seal on her entrance or something. She felt extremely warm, super slippery and so fucking tight that he wondered if he was in the right hole at first, or if she was a virgin, because ain't no way.

She was not a virgin, though, right? Yeah, nah.

"Hmm..." she whimpered and stopped for a second, which he was glad since it would have been game over for him if she didn't.

"You... you okay?" Eli asked her, trying to sound like he wasn't literally about to cum.

"Yeah..." she nodded, taking deep breaths.

"Take your time" he cooed before he kissed her. But she immediately pulled away.

"Hey..." she shakily whispered, moving her hips up a tiny bit before going lower. "No more kissing..."

"Why?" he frowned at her.

She completely stopped moving and just looked at him. Eli could see the usual and ever so present fear in her eyes, it was so clear. But why did she feel like that? Why right now, when the tip of his dick was inside of her? Confusion was becoming a part of his anatomy, at this point.

"Why not, Jess?" he asked again, bringing his lips closer to hers but she backed away.

"That's how you fall in... you know... what are you gonna do if that happens?" she tilted her head to the side and questionably stared at him. "What are you gonna do with that type of feelings, Eli?"

"Knit a blanket and cover you with it... from head to toe..." Eli immediately answered, as if it was a commonly known fact. He grabbed Jessica's chin and pulled her closer to him while looking at her eyes. "And I mean that."

Jessica's eyes narrowed at his answer so, before she could say anything else, he kissed her. Slowly. And for a minute, she kissed him back. When she pulled away, they looked at each other for some time, his dick inside her and all, before she averted her gaze.