An Unexpected Surprise [A Benstone Fan Fic]

-8-

Peter spent his weekend sleeping around with as many girls as he could find. He tried to pretend that he wasn't cheating on Olivia, but he felt like he was. He felt like he was the worst type of man. He was cheating on the woman he loved, and the woman who was giving him a baby.

Once Monday came around, he got a call from Fin and was told that they had a case. He drank his hangover cure and then got dressed and headed to the precinct. When he got there, he saw Olivia standing in the media area, as she and the crew went over the newest case. He watched her for a moment as she tucked some of her hair behind her ear, and absently placed her hand against her swell.

"Ah, Stone. Good. We have a man who was caught raping a girl who was unconscious. You are going to have a field day with this." Olivia spoke, as she picked up the file they had already gotten started and passed it to Peter.

"Great. Exactly how I want to start my week." He spoke. Olivia gave him a small nod as she walked back over to where she had stood before Peter showed up.

"We need as much background information on the rapist. So, Amanda and Carisi can do that. Fin, go to the hospital and check up on our vic. Peter, you are free to use what we have set up here. It isn't much, but we are working with what information we have at the moment." Olivia spoke. She walked to her office and her crew knew what that meant. They got up and left, while Peter sank down into one of the chairs and started to read from the file that had barely anything in it at the moment.

"Oh, uh, you left this at my house the last time you were there. I thought you might want it back." Olivia spoke, as she walked out and handed Peter his watch. He was wearing one, but the one she had in her hand was engraved and fancy.

"I thought I lost that forever. Thanks for giving it back." Peter spoke. He took it into his hand and put it into his pocket before standing.

"I can just call you once we have more information." Olivia breathed.

"Oh, yeah. Okay." He spoke. He looked at her for a moment, before turning and walking away without saying anything else.

---

They didn't get any further that night, so Olivia sent the crew home to get some sleep before coming in early the next morning to continue investigating. She went home and went right to bed because she had gotten up early to get Noah off to school and because she had just been uncomfortable. 

Peter didn't manage to get to sleep as quickly as Olivia did. He stayed awake and looked at the ceiling until someone knocked on his apartment door. He climbed out of bed and headed to answer it. He was hoping it was going to be Olivia, but instead, it was the girl he left behind in Chicago.

"Kathryn. What are you doing here?" He asked.

"You've been here for awhile, Peter. You promise me to call me and tell me when I could come out and join you. But I'm assuming you don't want me out here anymore." Kathryn huffed.

"I've been busy. The first few weeks I was dealing with my father's passing, then I got an ADA placement with Manhattan Sex Crimes, then Pamela got killed, then..." He didn't finish. He and Kathryn didn't really break up before he left Chicago, but they had grown apart and he had moved on. He just wishes she would've forgotten him and moved on too.

"Then what? Peter, you promised me." She frowned.

Kathryn and Peter went to college together, and then they also went to law school together. They had fallen in love and just lived their lives together in Chicago. Kathryn was Peter's age and had long brown hair and her eyes had really caught Peter's attention. They are dark green and striking.

"Kathryn, I think we need to talk. I've moved on, and I think you need to also."

"Peter! Just tell me really why you say that!" She yelled.

"I slept with another woman the night Pamela got killed. I got her pregnant." Peter whispered. Kathryn's eyes went wide.

"How dare you..." She huffed.

"Ryn! I'm sorry, it's just so much has happened and I was so upset. I just watched my sister get shot!" Peter exclaimed. Kathryn pushed him hard, and he stumbled a bit as she came into his apartment so they could fight in private.

"You said you loved me. You are a bastard!" She growled.

"Kathryn, I'm sorry." He breathed over and over again as Kathryn yelled at him. He hated how she was making him feel bad about sleeping with Olivia and getting her pregnant. She was making him feel bad for wanting to be a father.

"Who is this slut? I'll go beat her up." Kathryn yelled.

"You will not! She's pregnant, Ryn. Geez." Peter huffed.

"She slept with you! Did she know that we were engaged?" Kathryn huffed. Peter ran the hand over the back of his neck and shook his head.

"No, because we didn't give each other our relationship status before fucking. Okay? It isn't her fault. This is my fault so take it out on me!"

"Tell me, Peter Stone! Tell me who made you break your promise to me! Who is having your child, when we both know I should!"

"Her name is Olivia. That's all you are getting because I will not let you get in contact with her and hurt her. Just go back to your hotel and we can talk more tomorrow when we've both calmed down." Peter breathed.

"I'll find her, I can promise you that, asshole."

Kathryn slapped Peter once just for good measure, before storming out of his apartment. Peter ran his hands over his face as he started to freak out. He didn't want Kathryn to go over and hurt Olivia. Or to make her feel bad. He was the one who pushed a little too far and ended up sleeping with Olivia.

Hey guys! Thanks for reading! Please vote and comment all of your feedback below! :D