An Unexpected Surprise [A Benstone Fan Fic]

-9-

Olivia was opening the front door to her house to grab the newspaper because Noah loved reading the comics before school and she loved to hear his laughing before having to head to a place where she only sees darkness.

"Are you Olivia Benson?" A woman's voice asked. Olivia jumped a bit as she straightened up. She nodded as she saw the woman walking up her walkway.

"I am. Can I help you?" She asked. The woman walked up and slapped Olivia across her cheek and Olivia stumbled back into the wall of her house and gasped from the sudden contact.

"You'll pay for what you did, bitch." The woman spat, before turning and running back down the path. Olivia slowly walked into the house and shut and locked the door as her heart started to beat hard in her chest. She was scared, and her first thought was to call Peter.

"Liv?" Peter yawned as he answered his phone.

"Can you come over right now? As quickly as you can?" Olivia questioned, as a few tears ran down her cheeks. She let them fall as she ran her hand over her swell.

"What happened? Are you and the baby okay?" He asked, panicked.

"Some woman was waiting outside of my house and slapped me. She knew my name and called me a bitch. I don't know what I did or who she was, but I'm freaking scared. Please." She begged. 

Peter knew that it was Kathryn. He knew that she'd be back until he can get her to leave.

"Of course. I'll be there in 15 minutes. Just stay inside the house. I have the spare key."

---

Peter arrived at Olivia's house and unlocked her front door. Once inside, he called her name. She came out of the kitchen and quickly hugged him.

"Thank you so much for coming over." She whispered as she rested her head against his chest. Peter wrapped his arms around her and kissed the top of her head. He needed to hold her one last time before she finds out.

"Of course. We may not be on the best terms, but I'm always here for you. Tell me what this woman looks like." Peter spoke, as Olivia continued to hug him.

"Young, long brown hair, green eyes. She was younger, maybe your age." Olivia spoke, before stepping back and wrapping her arms around her stomach.

"Okay." He spoke, as he frowned a bit.

"Peter, who would do that? I have never seen her before, and she comes here and says I'll pay! Pay for what?!" Olivia exclaimed. Peter followed her back into the kitchen.

"Do you still have your security cameras outside?" Peter asked, and Olivia nodded.

"Yeah, I have them pulled up on my laptop. All I can think about is if Noah had been with me, or if she decided not to slap me but to hit my stomach or something." Olivia breathed. She started to feel even more anxious than earlier, and she started to pace the kitchen.

Peter sat down at the table and saw Kathryn as she parked and waited outside of Olivia's house. She waited till Olivia got the newspaper before going up. It pissed him off so much that he'd come and hurt a pregnant woman. Especially one that is pregnant with his child.

"Okay, Liv, just don't worry about this. We will figure this out. Sit down, I'll make you something to eat." Peter spoke, as he shut the laptop and stood up.

"Peter-" She started, but he shook his head as he grabbed her waist and drew her close.

"Don't worry. Nothing will happen to you, the baby, or Noah."

---

Olivia went to work and was very nervous. Every time her hearing focused on the ding of the elevator, she'd watch to see if that girl was there. While Peter was supposed to be at the precinct helping out the crew with the case, he was trying to track down Kathryn instead.

He went to her hotel, but she wasn't there. He tried to call her, but once again she wasn't answering. He drove to the precinct, wondering if she had just given up, but then he saw her walking up the steps and into the precinct.

"Kathryn!" He yelled as he climbed out after parking.

"I'm going to make her pay! She slept with my fiance!" Kathryn yelled.

"Ryn, please! Please don't hurt her! She's pregnant!" Peter spoke, as he ran after her. She got into the elevator, and the doors closed before Peter could get into it. He went sprinting towards the stairs and made it to the SVU floor before the elevator did. He grabbed Kathryn by her arm when she got out.

"What do you think you are going to be able to do to the CO of this unit? She has officers in there ready to arrest you. And I'm here. I will make sure you get arrested if you hurt her." Peter spat.

"You are more protective of a one night stand than you are of me! I'm your fiance, Peter!" Kathryn yelled.

She did what she intended, and Peter knew when Kathryn smiled. Peter turned around and saw Olivia standing in the doorway of SVU, and she was crying.

"Yeah, bitch. You deserve everything bad in your life. You slept with my fiance. You are a homewrecking slut!" Kathryn yelled. Olivia looked at Peter before wiping tears from her cheeks.

"You didn't tell me that you were engaged, Peter... I'm so sorry... I-i didn't know..." Olivia wiped another tear from her cheek before swallowing hard.

"Liv-"

"No, Peter. You should've told me. I'm a horrible woman thanks to you. Just leave, now. Leave and make up with your fiance. Don't come near me. I'll get another ADA to work on this case." Olivia huffed. She turned on her heel and quickly walked towards her office.

"Olivia!" Peter called after her, but he was torn. 

Does he go after her and try to fix what they have?

Or does he try and make up with Kathryn and try to get her to forgive him for cheating on her?

Either way, he was going to hurt the other, even if he didn't want to.

Hey guys! Thanks for reading! This chapter was based on a suggestion from Elliot_Sebastian! Please vote and comment all of your feedback below! :D