Always

Chapter 10

His eyes shot to me, and got a mischievous glint to them. F*ck. "Asked someone to marry me." He finished. I glared at him, about to remind him that he was playing dirty, when Kat spoke up. "Actually babe, you have." His head shot around to her. "Huh? When?" "Remember the prank that you thought you were pulling on me a couple of years back? You asked me to marry you." He started getting flustered and stuttering. "B-but that was a j-joke." She laughed and I interjected, slapping my hand across his leg. "Doesn't matter Brother, you didn't specify. Technically, you asked someone to marry you too, so drink up!" "Damn it, that backfired on me." He exclaimed.  I held my full shot glass up and towards him. "Drink up brother." I said, smiling. I winked at him and we both tossed back our shots. He refilled them both and looked at me. "Guess it's your turn." I nodded and sat back, pulling y/n against me. "Okay...Never have I ever dated more than one person at a time." "F*ck you bro." Brennen replied, grabbing a shot glass. S sat forward, reaching for one too. Sam grabbed one, and glared at me. "You know that I did in high school. Are you coming for me Colby?" I laughed, and felt Y/N strain against my arms, sitting up. "What are you doing?" I asked. "Getting a shot dummy." My eyebrows shot up in surprise. "Wait, what? Why?" She downed the last shot and looked back at me. "Duuuhh," She replied drunkenly. "Married but dating you. Did you forget already?" She lay back against me, grabbing my hands and pulled my arms back around her. "Oh yea...I did forget actually." I looked at Sam. "See, It was random. I wasn't coming for you brother." I smiled innocently. "Yeah, Okay. Next person." Babe, you're up." I told y/n. "Okay, I have a good one." She smiled and leaned forwards on my lap. "Never have I ever had a threesome." I hung my head. I had "accidentally" forgotten to mention this story to her. Brennen was looking at me, his eyes wide. He leaned forwards to grab a refilled shot. I didn't move at first but I saw Sam staring at me. "Well?" He said, motioning towards the glasses. I tried to shut him up with my eyes, but Y/N noticed. "COLBY?! Really?!" She started laughing. "OmG, I have to hear this story. Who was it with?" "Damn it," I growled leaning taking the shot glass that she offered me. At this rate, I was going to be pretty drunk, pretty soon. I looked at Brennen and we downed them together. Y/n noticed the interaction and screamed, laughing. "No you did not! Oh my God! S, did you know about this?" Serena had been watching us too. "It was a long time ago in Australia with a girl named Jade. We didn't touch each other, and we didn't make eye contact." Brennen put his glass down on the table and sat back. "Why do I find that hot?" Serena asked, looking at Brennen with her eyes wide. He glanced up at her. "Really?" he asked surprised. "Okay, before things go any further, Brennen, it's your turn." Y/N turned her head back towards me. "You had a threesome with Brennen? Why am I just now finding out about this?" She had a soft smile on her pink lips. I felt my face heat up and closed my eyes for a minute. "It's not something I advertise. I didn't think it was important. I don't even think about it anymore." She laughed. "Are you blushing Colby Brock?" "No!" I exclaimed. "Shut up y/n." I pulled her back and scraped my teeth on her neck, gently biting her in her ticklish spot. She squealed and wriggled in my arms. "Okay, you guys can chill. Let me have my turn." I heard Brennen say. I leaned up and looked at him. "Continue." I said, holding one hand out towards him. "Never have I ever...no wait, I've done that....Okay, I've got one. Never....no, I've done that too. Sh*t, hold on a sec." He sat there thinking for a minute while we were dying laughing. "Okay, okay, I got it!" We quieted down and waited. "Never have I ever got it on in an elevator." I groaned throwing my head back. "Really?!" I said exasperatedly. Y/N grabbed 2 shot glasses, passing one to me, Kat grabbed 2, passing one to Sam. "Um, guys we're gonna need refills." I heard Tara reply. I almost choked on my shot from laughing. Sam refilled the empties and passes 2 to Tara and Jake. "Corey and Dev?" Sam asked, holding out another two. They glanced at each other and reached for the glasses. "So you guys are seriously the only ones that haven't done it in an elevator?" Y/N asked, looking at Serena with surprise. She looked sideways at Brennen. "I guess we'll have to rectify that, huh babe?" He smiled at her. "I guess so." He leaned in to kiss her. Things started getting heated so I interrupted. "Okay S, it's your turn!" She broke the kiss, looking over at me annoyed. "You're just cock blocking everyone tonight aren't you Cole." I shrugged and laughed. "Pay back for all the times I've been interrupted." She huffed and sat back. "Never have I ever done it outside." "Okay when did this just go straight sexual?" Kat asked, grabbing a shot. Everyone ended up getting a shot on that one, except Serena. "I feel like I'm missing out on something." She whimpered. "We'll fix it." Brennen whispered not so quietly in her ear. "Devyn, your turn." Y/N said. I was really starting to feel all of this liquor. My face was hot, and the room was a little spinny if I turned my head too fast. I was going to regret standing up when the time came. "Okay," She said softly. "Uum, Never have I ever...slept with twins." Brennen picked up a shot.