Home Sweet Home [PLL]

Scream for Me

"What the hell is this?" Lily asked when she began to flick through a sketchbook Aria had put in front of her. The pages were covered in graphic drawings of death, devils and anger

"This was Bethany Young's" She said "I got it from Radley"

"What are these of?" She asked

"Mrs D," Aria answered and pointed to a blonde woman in one of the pictures who had been drawn with devil horns and her mouth wide open as though screaming

Lily's eyes widened and she looked up at Aria "You don't think-"

"Bethany left Radley to try find Mrs D and A killed her instead of Ali that night? Yeah" She nodded 

"God this is insane" Lily whispered 

"I know" Aria said "I'm heading back to Radley this evening to see if I can find out any more about how Bethany knew Mrs D and what she was doing the night she died"

"Ok" Lily nodded "I'll see you later"

Lily headed home at the end of the school day and she was sitting in her living room as Caleb walked past for the front door

"Where you going?" She asked him

"My uncle's cabin" He answered "With Hanna"

"I need to talk to you" Lily sighed and stood up "I'm worried about Hanna, she's been drinking a lot, she's dressing like me, and she isn't acting like herself anymore. Please just keep an eye on her and don't let her keep spiralling like this"

"Let me get this straight" He chuckled "You want me to keep an eye on Hanna because you don't like her behaviour, but her behaviour is exactly like yours"

"No hers is worse!" Lily exclaimed "She's been drinking in school, Caleb."

"That's her choice" He shrugged "I'm not telling her what to do"

"Caleb she's been going downhill since Ali came back-"

"Maybe because she's finally tired of being bossed around by her" He said "Meanwhile the rest of you are still under her thumb at every turn"

"You don't know shit about me and Ali," Lily snapped "She's my sister and she's been through hell. She's looking over her shoulder every day because of how scared she is"

"Why does it have to involve Hanna then?" He said "Ali's got the rest of you so let Hanna go"

"Caleb you've seen what's happened to me, do you really want Hanna to go down the same path?" She asked

"What I want is for Hanna to do whatever Hanna wants" He replied "Just because you're a screw up doesn't mean she'll become one" Lily froze and Caleb knew he had gone too far "Lily-"

"Get out" She whispered "Get the fuck out. Go to your cabin and stay there. Don't you dare come back"

Caleb took a step towards her but she passed him and went up to her room, tears silently building in her eyes until she heard the front door close and she let the tears roll down her cheeks

At school the next day Lily couldn't see Hanna which was a relief since she knew Caleb would have told her about their fight

But luckily it turned out Aria had found out that Mrs D used to take Bethany Young to some stables outside of Lewisburg, and after some research she had found the name of the stables

So after school Lily, Spencer, and Emily drove out to Lewisburg to the Tilting Windmill Equestrian Centre

As they walked in they saw a man outside brushing one of the horses "Are you Declan?" He nodded "Hi. The lady inside said you were the one to talk to for lessons."