My Step Brother's Obsession - Carly #2

Carly Sandwich Pt 1

Carly

I woke to be smashed in between Jonathan and Kyler. Jonathan's fingers grazed my mound. He slid them down and up rhythmically. I swallowed a moan. "I know you're awake, Carly Bear."

My eyes jerked open, and he slid his finger into my hole. "Keep your eyes on my angel."

I nodded as he pumped his finger in and out, rubbing my clit. I moaned lowly, trying not to wake Kyler.

"Mmm, I could get used to this every morning." Kyler hummed, kissing my shoulder. His hand hovered over my ass cheeks pinching and molding them as Jonathan slid another finger inside me and began fucking his fingers into me faster, rubbing my clit harder. I moaned out, not giving a shit there were three of us in bed.

"Put your leg over J's angel." Kyler breathed sexily into my ear, sending shudders down my spring. Never in a million years would I have thought that I would be in a three-way relationship with these two. They've always been over-flirty with me, but I ignored it, thinking it was their usual banter because I was with Aiden.

I did as he said. And I felt his slick finger slide down my backbone to my ass bone. "This may hurt a little angel, but it will get you ready for my dick."

He slid his finger into my ass and I cringed gasping. "It's okay angel, you'll get used to it."

He began to slide it in and out feeling a little uncomfortable, but my mind was hazy with pleasure from Jonathan's finger fucking me and playing with my clit. I hadn't noticed he had slid another one in and began fucking my ass with his fingers. I panted and moaned as they continued to pleasure me. Jonathan's lips seized mine in a mad, passionate kiss. Kyler latched his lips onto my shoulder, kissing and sucking it. Their movements became more frantic as my body began to shake "cum for us angel."

My orgasm blew me away as it took over. My eyes rolled back, and I was panting and moaning. I was shaking as they continued to finger both of my holes.

Once I had come down from my orgasm, they slid their fingers out. "We're going to fuck you together Carly Bear."

I swallowed hard. I've never had anything up my ass and I knew a dick was way bigger than fingers.

"It's okay Carly Bear, relax. We're double-dipping. We know you're not great for anal just yet."

What the hell was double-dipping?

"I'm going to enter you first, angel, then Kyler will okay?"

I just nodded, not knowing what to say.

With one swift push, he was in and sated l. "It's okay, Carly Bear. We won't hurt you. You'll enjoy it. I promise."

I nod.

Jonathan smiled. "Just remember to say red if it gets too much, okay."

I nod.

"Words Carly Bear."

"Okay I will."

"Hold tight, angel."

He began to move slowly, hitting the right place, and I moaned. He pulled out and slammed back inside me. I moaned again. He gave me a few more hard thrusts, and then I felt fingers slide inside me, not sure how many, but I heard Jonathan groaning, his cock further inside me, making me gasp. The fingers disappeared. And I felt like I was being stretched beyond my capability of stretching. Kyler's breath hit my ear, sending tingles down my entire body. "You're doing so well angel, you're getting my dick so well. Well, give you time to adjust to the both of us being inside you, then we'll continue, okay?"

I nodded.

A few minutes passed, and I told them I was ready, but was I really ready for this?

They worked in sync. Kyle pulled out and Jonathan pulled out when he slammed back inside me and vice versa until I was a mess of orgasms and hot, sweaty slicked bodies, fucking so hard that our orgasms congealed into one as we all came together.

Jonathan

I couldn't believe Ky did that when he was stretching her a little more. We'd fucked a girl at the same time before and his touch had never felt like that before. It sent an electrical current straight through my dick. I had no idea what he was playing at. I let out a groan I couldn't keep in and pushed my dick further into our angel, and she moaned like an angel as I did.

Once he was inside her, I couldn't help the way his dick felt against mine. Most girls didn't like double-dipping, but our angel was taking it all. It was making me so fucking hard I knew I wasn't going to last long at this rate after his fingers had brushed me lightly across my cock whilst I was inside her, intensifying my need to bury myself deep inside of her. His dick rubbing against mine didn't quell the orgasm that was rippling inside me and threatening to explode any second.

A few more rough jagged thrusts had us all in blissful heaven in something I had never thought was even possible, not until now. We all lay silently together, our dicks shrinking, then and only then did I pull out of her slippery pussy. "I think we need to eat after all of that exercise. " I said, grinning.

They both rolled their eyes and made no attempt to get up. I sighed and walked into the bathroom naked.

Kyler

That had got to be the hottest thing I had ever done, J and I often shared girls, but mine were hers. None were our Carly Bear. She was something else. We once thought she would be disgusted at the thought of us sharing her, but she couldn't have one of us without the other. She liked us both for who we were. We were on different sides of the spectrum, but we worked well together.

It was the first time that I had felt J's anatomy in a long time. Girls we have been with in the past liked to see the other side of us. We would give it but Calry is different. I don't want her to ever see that side, or find out about it.

It was a mistake touching him like I had, but I wanted to feel him just once, one more time before we couldn't again. The gruntal moan that came out of his mouth I knew I was different from that and when my dick slid into Calry's sweet tight pussy I felt his dick and it pulsing inside her and I almost came, without anything but his dick touching mine.

I had to reel it in. I wanted this. I wanted to fuck her senseless in her puss, in her way and in her mouth. It's just a pity we've chosen not to show our true selves to her.

We left that out because we didn't want her to see us differently.

Jonathan had left the bed and headed to the bathroom to freshen up whilst I held Carly in my arms, not wanting to let go for another few minutes. At least, she was my home. My comfort. "I love you Carly Bear."

"I love you too."

I kissed her shoulder, holding her tight. "I want to have you in all ways possible. I want to be the first to take your virgin ass. Is that okay?"

She nodded and I smiled.

J walked back in freshly showered. "I'll go cook us something whilst you both go and freshen up.

"Sure J."

He smiled, winking.

He strode out of the room and closed the door behind him. "Come on angel, let's get freshened up and join J for breakfast."

She nodded and I pulled out of her. We had all made sure we were clean and that Carly had been put on some kind of contraceptive before we took our relationship to the next level. We pulled ourselves up and headed to the bathroom for a not-so-innocent shower.