My Step Brother's Obsession - Carly #2

You Lied To Me!

Kyler

The car was stiffening as we headed home. This wasn't how this weekend was supposed to go. We were supposed to sit down and air out all of our problems so we could work out how to fix them then Jonathan threw a curveball and it ended up turning on its axis. I couldn't believe how stupid I had been to fall for his bullshit about us both needing to stay late at work. I had no idea he was fucking around. It felt like he wasn't only cheating on Calry, but me as well. I thought that I knew him, but I didn't know him at all.

We had been friends since we were seventeen. It had taken that long to realise that we were in the same team. Like Cas had always said: there was no I in team.

He was right and we became good friends, the best I thought I truly knew him until he had pulled this stunt dragging me with him so he had an alibi so he could get his end away with some hoe. I was stuck in the office making sure that everything was up to date with the pepper work and everything was in order for the following day. I had no idea he was sneaking off to fuck some chick or guy whilst I was done all the fucking work even if I had prepared it earlier that day I mad sure I had put made any mistakes and that everything was in order.

I was unaware of his activities in his office. He said he was going to do the spreadsheets that needed to go to Cas for any new gear we needed and make sure that the food for the kitchen had been ordered correctly. I was so fucking blind and stupid not to realise he playing me for a fool. The guy I trusted with my life was using me to get his rocks off whilst Carly was at home waiting for us. Fuck it made me feel sick.

Once we were home I bolted inside and threw my ring up until there was nothing left inside me even bile. I wiped my mouth and used a ton of mouthwash to take away the taste of puel or I would be sure to throw up again.

Csrly had asked me if I was okay I nodded but I was far from, okay this would be the first night all wn without her sleep next to me until she decided to put some trust back into Jonathan fuck knows how long that will take care this confession.

I went to bed alone, finding it hard to sleep without Carly by my side. I finally fell asleep at one and was woken by my alarm at six am to get ready for work. I walked sleepily into the kitchen where Jonathan and Carly sat looking equally unrested. I'm surprised they are sitting in the same space though the was defining and the ide cold air cut be cut through with a knife. I wondered how long this shit was going to last as I got breakfast.

Once breakfast was over and done with, we went to our separate rooms, something that had never happened in the history of our relationship. If this was how a marriage ended, I never wanted to get married.

No matter how much I loved Carly I did not want to be like this hate brewing between us with The things that were left unsaid.

Once we had all used the bathroom and gotten dressed we all headed to work separately instead of together like we had done unless we of course were working late which had happened more than it should have over the past six months.

Fuck how stupid was I?

Now it's all gone to shit I'm not even sure Carly can ever forgive me for being Jontathan's scapegoat instead of coming home to be with the girl I loved unconditionally so much so I was going to talk to Jonathan and let him know our secret. But now that's all changed we'll never be able to tell her cause she'll never trust anything either of us will ever say again.

Fuck!

I don't know how long I can do this shit before I break.

We all pulled up outside work and all went out separateways without saying a word to one another.

Carly

I had to hold back the tears as I got out of my car and slammed the car door angrily. I had been doing this for the past six months convincing myself things would get better, yet they never did. I am finally out having a baby with the two men I loved the most in the world to the back of my head forgetting that I hadn't even considered it for a second let alone months before I had decided to talk to both of them and tell them that I was ready. Then things had gone downhill so fast I didn't know what day it was, which way was up and which way was down.

Both of them hadn't come home after work claiming they both needed to finish work off and hadn't come home until I was asleep. I had felt so alone so much so I had tried to ask them for time together so we could talk about our relationship and all I got was footbed off with pathetic excuses. I wished I had ended things once the excuses had begun but I truly thought that we could get past anything until Jonathan had dropped a bomb. I should've seen it coming but I hadn't. The only person I could trust enough to talk about was Star. So I headed inside and to her office I knew she would see me regardless.

I knocked on the Star's office door. She yells to come in and I enter closing the door. She smiles brightly at me. "So, how was your weekend?"

My bottom lip trembles.

"Oh, honey." She gets up from her chair and walks around to me and pulls me into a hug. "What happened hun."

"It was terrible." I burst into tears.

"Let's sit down and you can tell me how terrible it was."

I nod and she guides me over to the chairs and we both sit down facing each other. Usually, there aren't two seats together so she must've been in some kind of meeting or having an assessment. She passes me a tissue and I thank her, wiping my eyes and blowing my nose holding on to it like my life depends on it.

"So, what happened, Carly? You were all ready to head off to the cabin for the weekend to get your relationship back on track."

I tried to hold back the tears. "He cheated on me." I sobbed.

"Who?"

"Jonathan."

She looked at me, not at all surprised.

"You knew, didn't you?"

"He came to talk to me after Ethan left."

Of course, he would, feeling guilty and jealous.

"I advised him to tell you the truth so you could come back from it, pull your relationship back together and talk about his thoughts and feelings after a one-night stand."

"Is that what he told you?"

She nodded.

"It wasn't one night, it was six months. He'd lied to me for six months and pulled Ky into it so I wouldn't know."

Star

I looked at Carly's face and I knew she was telling me the truth how could I not tell Jonathan wasn't telling me the whole truth he had lied to me the MF had lied to me when I had asked him about cheating on Carly he had told me point blank it was a one-night stand and he had regretted it. Six months isn't regretting the first time when there are so many others that follow. I get Kyler was humming as well when he heard the truth for the first time fuck I felt so sick.

"I'm sorry Carly, I had no idea."

"None of us did. It's not your fault Star you were only trying to help."

"I feel I'm partly to blame. I should've pressed harder."

"He would've continued to lie to you like he has been lying to me for the past six months, I don't know what to do."

"I honestly don't know Carly the balls in your court. You need to ask yourself if you can ever trust him after this not to do it again."

"I don't know."

"You still have Ky."

"I don't want to ruin their friendship."

"I say Jonathan has done that all by himself. Give it time hun don't rush it if you can't ever trust him again you'll have to tell him you can no longer be with him but don't push Ky away he loves you and respects you. Don't push him away because of a friendship that is more than likely already broken. I reckon he'll make sure you know he won't put Jonathan before you in a heartbeat."

"I hope you're right if things don't work out."

"I know I'm right."