"What? He asked you to dinner? I'm surprised he forgave you for just leaving." Sam states in shock as you three and Cas settle into a motel not far from the woods where the four victims were disappearing.
"Remember, we had no choice but to leave." You reminded Sam, staring at him.
"What happened?" Cas questioned, confused on yours and Connors story.
"Nothing, it's no big deal." You shook it off, nervously.
"Look, we went to the principal and she showed us the crime scene photos that the local sheriff showed her." Dean pointed out, taking out the photos from his bag.
You take one photo and examine it. "Wait, I know these markings. It looks like a-"
"Werewolves." Sam finishes. You nodded.
"I'm going to go pick up dinner. Sam?" Dean nods to Sam for him to go with him. "Keep an eye out for anything suspicious here and we'll do the same out there." Dean reminded you and Cas.
You tossed the photo on the counter and answered.
"Sure." You nodded simply. You drag yourself over to the bed to throw yourself on it.
"Listen, you don't have to tell me what exactly happened, but Connor seems like a nice man." Cas mentioned, sitting on the edge of the other bed.
You sighed out heavily and sat up. You cupped your knees to your chin, "He was the sweetest, most kind hearted man I have ever loved. Then I met you." You glanced over at Cas, who seemed relieved you spoke those words. "And I just left him. No explanation, just a vague letter I left him in his locker." You scoffed, hating to remember how you treated Connor. "I was awful."
"Like you said, you had no choice." Cas reminded you to make you stop being so hard on yourself.
"Yeah. I thought he was going to be the one. The one I marry and start a family with." You sighed out in disappointment, "Oh well." You shrugged.
Suddenly, you and Cas heard something from outside of the woods.
"What was that?" You questioned, shooting up from the bed. You followed Cas, who had his blade in his hand as you took yours out.
Cas slowly opened the door, with the woods where all the disappearing has been occurring.
"AHHHH!" You heard screaming from the woods that seemed like you and Cas were close. You pulled out your phone quickly as you and Cas ran towards the scream and texted Sam.
"You go left and I'll go right!" You directed Cas who by his facial expression, didn't like the plan.
"We're not splitting up. That's a stupid idea." Cas shot at you.
"Are you ser-" Another scream echoed in the woods, interrupting yours and Castiels fight.
You ran towards the direction to get more closely to it and heard Cas warn you to stay by his side.
Suddenly, you stopped behind a tree and see that there were a man standing in front of a girl who was tied up against the tree. All of a sudden, his body grew fur and his fingernails grew long, looking exactly like a werewolf.
"What do we got?" A voice from behind you made you have a jump scare, revealing Sam and Dean.
"Okay, me and you will distract them on one side and Sam and Dean, you will do the other side, okay?" You demanded. They nodded at the plan and began the mission.
"Please, don't hurt me." The girl whimpered for her life but the werewolf showed no mercy until you jumped on his back, having Castiel help you pin him down to the floor.
Doing this unsuccessfully, Cas gets thrown against the tree and you get thrown in the air and get slammed on the grass. The werewolf revealed his teeth to you and you didn't flinch one bit. You kicked him off of you but he got caught by slicing your right side with his nails.
You winced at the pain and realized it was deeper than you thought it was. The werewolf grinned with his teeth shining. You grunted, struggling to stand.
"Hey, Buffy!" Dean yelled to get his attention. Doing so, you grabbed your silver blade and your wobbly feet rush over to him and stab him in the back. He yelled and screamed as you jabbed it in there more. You held your side that was bleeding uncontrollably.
"Guys! Get her out of here!" You yelled, getting their attention as you were losing your balance and your breath. You felt someone behind you hold your side and you turned around, revealing Connor.
"Hey, Y/N, it's me. Connor." He revealed himself and you fell into his arms, everything turning black.
