Leo: He would be so proud of whatever you gave him. He didn't care if if was self made, small, old. He would touch it whenever he could. He might take it with him to battle as a good luck charm but he won't wear / use it on a daily basis, he just too afraid of losing or breaking it.
Raph: He would try to take it with him wherever he goes. If it's something small, he might put it in his pocket and make sure that one is closed so he won't lose it. He would play with it here and there, especially if he's angry or nervous. Normally you were the one calming him down but if you weren't there your gift must suffice.
Donnie: Donnie would put your present up on a shelf. So that no one (I'm looking at you Mikey) can touch or break it. He would always smile whenever he looked at it. He would admire it as often as he could. It reminded him of you, even if you weren't in the lair with him you felt close.
Mikey: Depending on what it is, he would wear it every single day. And night. He would be excited no matter what it was, because it was special to him. YOU gave this to him, YOU thought about him. He would cherish your present and always show it off to his brothers, no matter how many times they've seen it.

YOU ARE READING
TMNT x Reader | Song preferences | Imagines
FanfictionTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Favorite songs. Imagines. Sometimes fluff, sometimes smut.