Hiccup x oc oneshots

125- love is love

So this is a joint chapter with bluejay_1111
Contains polyamory. If you aren't comfortable with that, give it a miss.

Hiccup is 21, south is 21, bluejay is 21

Hiccup's p.o.v

I gaze at the picture of south on my phone longingly. God, why is love so complicated? I mean, I love bluejay. She is my soulmate, but I can't get this woman out of my head. I decide I need to talk to bluejay about this. She always knows what to say. I slip my phone into my pocket and head into the living room. Bluejay is watching tv, but she's obviously deep in thought
"Blue" I say, getting her attention. She looks over at me
"Yeah?"
"I need to talk to you about something" I say, sitting on the other end of the couch.
"What's the matter?" She asks me.
"I... do you remember south?" For some reason, she blushes
"Y-Yeah, why?"
"I don't know why, but I can't get her out of my head. I love you, more than anything, but I think I love her too" She contemplates my words for a moments
"Gods, that woman. Hiccup, I've been feeling the same way. I don't know what it is about her, but I think she's got us both spinning out of control. I don't want to break up with you, because I love you" she says.
"So what do we do? We can't just carry on with our relationship knowing we both love someone else" I say. She thinks, then her eyes light up"
"Hiccup... have you ever heard the word 'polyamory'?" I feel like I've heard it somewhere before, but I can't match it to a definition. I tell her as much.
"It's the word for a relationship where there is more than two partners" I gasp.
"That's a thing?"
"Yeah. I don't know if south would be down for it, though" she says. I nod.
"Yeah, it does seem pretty taboo" I reply
"Doesn't mean we can't ask" she says
"B-but what if she thinks we're weird and never speaks to us again?"
"But what if she doesn't? What if she is willing to try? We could never ask her and our whole lives we could only wonder what she would have said. But if we ask, then we can at least live our lives knowing we tried"
"Damn you and your way with words. Okay, I'll shoot her a text and ask her to meet us at the lucky cat cafe" I say. She nods, so I grab my phone out of my pocket and send South a message, asking to meet up. She says okay.
'How is tomorrow at three'
'Good! See you then x' my heart thumps a little at the little x she put.

At the lucky cat cafe

Me and bluejay are sat at our usual table. Waiting. Right on three, the bell rings as south walks in.
"Timely, as usual" I comment. She grins as she sits down, a smile that makes my heart flutter
"I am nothing if not punctual" she replies.
"So, why did you ask me here?" Are you guys good?" I glance at bluejay
"Um, yeah. There is something we needed to tell you" I say nervously.
"What's going on?"
"Oh gods, how do we put this?" I slide my hand down my face
"Basically, me and hiccup cane to a sort of realisation yesterday"
"What?"
"We realised that both of us are in love with you" bluejay says seriously
"That's... one way to do it" I Saigon. Bluejay shrugs at me
"B-both of you?" She asks, shocked.
"Um, yeah." I say, rubbing the back of my neck
"Oh wow... of everything you could have said, that wasn't what I was guessing" she gives a light laugh.
"What does this mean for you two? I don't want to get in the way of your relationship" she say. Me and bluejay glance at each other
"Do you have any feeling towards us?" Bluejay asks her. South blushes an adorable pink and gives a slow nod
"Um, yeah. That's how I discovered I was pansexual, because I loved you, bluejay. I love you, hiccup, just as much. I wasn't sure what that meant, so I tried to ignore it"
"So did we. We wanted to propose something" bluejay says
"What?"
"I did some research. Being in 3 way relationships is a thing. Is called polyamory. It's a bit taboo, but we can't be prosecuted for it" bluejay explains. Souths eyes light up.
"We can do that? Oh wow... so... hiccup, you'd have two girlfriends and me and bluejay would have a boyfriend and a girlfriend?" She confirms. We nod
"Yeah, basically. What d'you day? Wanna be our girlfriend?" Bluejay asks. My heart is pounding
"Yes! I would love to" she smiles. South leans in and presses a kiss against my lips, then a kiss on bluejays.
"Let's all go to our house?" I suggest. They both nod and we leave the cafe. Each girl is holding one of my hands. I have south on my right, and bluejay in my left. We get a lot of stares, but I have two beautiful women at my side, so who am I to complain? We soon arrive at home, and I take my coat off as the girls do. We head into the living room to watch a movie. We at some point end up in a position that has bluejay laying between my legs, her head resting on my chest and south is laying against my side, her head rested between my chin and the top of bluejays head. She has her arm crossed over bluejay.
"I'll get some snacks" I murmur to the girls.
"Okay" souths day. We all untangle ourselves, and I head into the kitchen. I begin making some popcorn. Once it's done, I head back into the living room to find them both on their knees, locked in a heated makeout. Some would get jealous, but me? I get an instant hard on. I make my way over to them, placing to bowl down
"Starting without me?" I chuckle darkly
"If not now, when?" South says breathily. I tilt her head to capture her lips with my own as bluejays hands wander my body.
"Lets take this to the bedroom, shall we?" I whisper huskily as I pull away from south. They both nod and we all go upstairs, promptly shitting the door.
"What d'you say south, wanna give hiccup the time of his life?" Bluejays smirks, and so does south.
"I think I like that idea" she replies. The both push me back onto the bed. They stay standing up, and begin kissing again. I feel my boner grow at just how hot this is. South begins to take of her shirt, so bluejay joins. Soon, both are stripped to their undergarments and I'm fighting with myself to not start palming the tent in my pants
"D'you think he's suffered enough?" Bluejay asks. South smirks and nods
"Yeah." They come at me. Bluejay straddles my chest and leans down to join her lips to mine. South pushes my shirt up and starts kissing my stomach, right at the rim of my pants. I let out a small moan against bluejays lips. South pulls my pants and boxers down, so my erection springs free. She throws them somewhere in the room. I unclip bluejays bra, and I hear a quiet click coming from souths. Then south comes next to me, laying her front down l so that she can kiss my neck, her hand trailing down my abdomen and grabbing my member in a soft hand. I moan and buck my hips. South chuckles and begins jerking me off and I can no longer properly maintain the kiss. I grab her thighs and pull her forward, so she's hovering above my face. I bury my face in her crotch, licking her furiously.
"Ahhh!" She moans loud, gripping the wall above the headboard. I feel souths mouth sink around me, and I moan against her, the vibrations obviously pleasuring her more in the way that she moans louder. My head spins at the pleasure I'm being given by south, an the pleasure I'm getting by getting bluejay off, the sweet taste of her in my tongue. Then, south pulls her mouth away, and I instinctively buck my hips, trying to get her to go back. Instead, I feel her position herself over me, before she sinks down. She lets out a long, loud moan.
"O-Oh gods" she cries out, reaching her hand down to rub the bit of me that isn't inside of her. She bounces up and down on my lap as I continue to lick and suck bluejay. Her thighs clench down around my head as she comes, her sweet juices spilling into my mouth. I feel my insides tighten as I come myself, and south does too. They both collapse at either side of me, each laying on one of my shoulders.
"Who knee three ways could be so mind blowing" I murmur. They both giggle.
"Bluejay, you lucky bitch, having him all to yourself for so long" south says, trailing her finger down my chest.
"I know, right?" She grins. I chuckle, kissing both of them before feeling myself fall asleep.