Sebastian and Rachel One Shots (Smytheberry)

141. First Time

Based on West Side Story. And instead of Blaine being Tony it's Sebastian. And after the slushie and blackmail Sebastian did, as punishment his dad made him go to Mckinley and be the lead of the West Side Story musical.

Rachel was upset that Sebastian had to be her Tony. She was furious that she couldn't have Blaine or even Kurt as her Tony, and it wasn't like Finn was wanting to be her Tony, not when he was too busy shoving his tongue down Quinn's throat, and as much as that angered her nothing angered more than having Sebastian as her Tony. The very person who blackmailed her, and slushied.

After they sang Artie had stopped them and questioned if either of them had done it before. Rachel was nervous she didn't want Sebastian to know that she wasn't as experienced as he is. Rachel knew the type of person Sebastian was, Rachel knew Sebastian is experienced and Rachel knew the reputation of Sebastian.

Rachel had walked out of the rehearsal not wanting to answer Artie's question. Sebastian was confused as to why Rachel walked out of rehearsal. Sebastian chased after her.

"Rachel, wait up." Rachel turned around and said

"What Sebastian?" Sebastian knew something was up and said

"I want to know why you walked out? I know you are angry and upset that I'm your Tony and not Blaine I get it Rach." Rachel softly

"You don't get it. And you won't Sebastian." Sebastian folded his arms to look at her and said

"Try me." Rachel took Sebastian's hand and lead him to an empty classroom. She closed the door and turned to Sebastian who said

"If you wanted me alone all you had to do was ask." Rachel rolled her eyes and said

"Do you want to get it or not?" Rachel blushed at her words and quickly said as Sebastian smirked

"Not like that." Sebastian sat on the table in the classroom and said

"I'm listening." Rachel felt silly with talking about it and said

"It's embarrassing, the reason I walked out is because when Artie asked us that, I felt embarrassed because unlike you I'm not experienced." Sebastian stood up and walked over to Rachel and said

"You know they're rumours right? What you hear about me they're rumours." Rachel was confused and Sebastian continued

"I'm like you. I don't have the experience either. What you and everyone hears about me with my reputation and sleeping with a lot of girls are rumours that I made up." Rachel was even confused and said

"Why would you make it up, something like a first time is an important thing Sebastian, especially to me." Rachel turned to leave when Sebastian said

"I made them up to impress you." Rachel stopped walking as he continued

"I know it isn't my smartest move but I thought if you heard that about me, you would notice me, and you would be impressed, it's also why I blackmailed you, it was never for you to quit regionals I knew that would never happen, it was for you to notice me, and the slushie wasn't even meant for Blaine or even Kurt it was actually meant for Finn. I thought if I tossed at him, you would see me." Rachel turned around to face him and said

"Why is it so important that I notice you, that I see you Sebastian?" Sebastian knew it was time to come clean

"Because I love you. And I'm willing to be around Kurt for you, and I'm willing to put my bullying and to put my horrible reputation and the rumours to bed for you. I'm wanting to change for you because I love and I don't want anyone else but you and I'll do anything for you." Rachel was speechless at Sebastian's love confession, and she looked at Sebastian in a way she's never done before. Rachel walked towards him and kissed him. As they kissed they knew in their hearts what they wanted.

Sebastian pulled Rachel closer and when they pulled apart and he rested his forehead against Rachel's, he said

"You want to go to my dorm?" Rachel knew in her heart that she wanted her first time to be with Sebastian and only Sebastian. She nodded her head and let Sebastian lead her to his dorm.

As they arrived at Dalton and went to Sebastian's dorm, Sebastian looked down at her as he gently laid her on his bed

"I'm not a rebound from Finn right, and you aren't wanting to doing this for the role?" Rachel kissed him and said

"You are definitely not a rebound, and I want this because I love you, and I don't want anyone else to have this but you." Sebastian smiled widely and kissed her passionately.

And what followed was blissful love and passion and as they laid there Sebastian smiled at her and said

"I love you." Sebastian leaned forward to kiss her and rolled her over for round 2.

And when it came to opening night of West Side Story. Rachel was no longer upset that Sebastian was her Tony. She and Sebastian both were actually happy and loved every minute, and Sebastian even convinced Rachel to go to Crawford to be away from the bullying and spent every lunch time and after school together, and being able to share their love to the world much to the anger and disappointment of Kurt and Finn.