Sebastian and Rachel One Shots (Smytheberry)

55. Give him a chance

Marley is dating Skylar and she knew of Sebastian's feelings for her older sister. She was home with her sister as their dads were at work, she walked up to her sister's bedroom, leaned on the door frame and said

"You know what would be so great Rach?" Rachel was standing in front of her mirror turned to face her sister and said

"What would be so great Marls?" Marley smiled brightly at her older sister and said

"If you gave Sebastian a chance." Rachel folded her arms, narrowed her eyes at her younger sister and said

"Why would I give him a chance, he blackmailed me and slushied Blaine which resulted him in having an eyepatch and almost going blind." Marley knew the real reason for Sebastian's actions, with dating Skylar and sitting down talking to Sebastian, she knew his reasons wasn't anything bad, it was because of having feelings for Rachel, and not knowing what to do about them, Marley walked in Rachel's room and said

"Maybe he had his reasons for them. Rachel, I wouldn't tell you to give Sebastian a chance if I know he would hurt you." Rachel shook her head at what her sister had said and she said

"Marley, he has hurt me, he ruined my relationship with Finn." Marley sat on Rachel's bed and said

"Who cheated on you with Quinn multiple times and slept with Santana in the past and the blackmail was a photo of Finn and not you." Rachel folded her arms and said

"He almost blinded Blaine." Marley shook her head at her sisters excuses and said

"Who was in the wrong place at the wrong time, and defended Kurt who was defending Finn." Rachel paced in her room and said

"He calls me names Marley, he insults me." Marley sighed and said

"No he doesn't, he calls you Broadway, Barbra, Streisand, Rachel, Berry. I highly doubt they are insults Rach, if anything the first three names are compliments." Rachel stopped pacing, Marley stood up and stood in front of her sister and said

"Rachel, you wasted so many years on Finn, Jesse, and Finn again, that you won't give one guy who has only ever complimented you, did it ever occur to you that Sebastian only done what he done, because he doesn't know what to do, because you won't give him a chance and won't talk to him even though you want to." Marley then walked out of Rachel's room, leaving Rachel alone to process what she had said. Rachel thought back to her encounters with Sebastian, and she realised Marley was right, he has never hurt her. Rachel picked up her keys, walked out of her room, and drove to Dalton when she reached her car. Marley smiled at seeing her sister walk out of the house, as she hopes that Rachel is going to Sebastian.

Rachel reached Dalton, got out the car, and walked inside the school, and walked to the warble room. She opened the doors and as she did she saw Sebastian talking to Skylar, who then looked up, saw Rachel, and then walked out, leaving Rachel with Sebastian. Rachel walked in, and said

"Why did you do it?" Sebastian knew instantly what she was talking about, and he said

"Because I want you." Rachel couldn't believe it, why would anyone want her, she folded her arms and said

"You have a funny way in showing it." Sebastian walked around her, closed the doors, locked them, turned to her and said

"You think I actually blackmailed you, to get you to drop out of regionals." Rachel narrowed her eyes at him and said

"You ruined my relationship." Sebastian walked over to her and said

"With someone who never deserved you at all, because all he ever does is hurt you and chooses cheerleaders over you, which is the stupidest thing he has ever done, but I should be happy, because it means you are free of him, and you can give me a chance." Rachel couldn't believe what she is hearing, she took a step back from him and walked towards the doors and said

"I will never give you a chance, you almost blinded Blaine." Sebastian took a step forward towards her and said

"I was aiming for Finn, because he hurt you, and I was jealous that he had you, Kurt got in the way, and then Blaine got in the way, I was never aiming for Blaine, and the rock salt was to only keep it cold in transportation." Rachel was trapped between the door and Sebastian and said

"I don't believe you." Sebastian placed his forehead against Rachel's, and he knew the effect he had on her, he took a gamble and kissed her. Rachel didn't kiss back, Sebastian, pulled back, lifted his hand to her cheek, softly stroked, leaned forward once more, and whispered against her lips and said

"Give in Broadway, I know you want to, you owe it to yourself Streisand." Sebastian kissed her again, and this time Rachel gave into him. She had to admit, he was a good kisser, and she has never been kissed like that before. They pulled apart once more, Sebastian looked at her in the eyes and said

"Believe me now." Rachel stared at Sebastian and melted into his green eyes, and before she knew it, she kissed him, they pulled apart, Sebastian took her hand, and said

"You are so beautiful Rachel." She blushed as she is never really complimented, Sebastian smirked, opened the warbler room doors, and lead her to his dorm, sebastian pushed Rachel against his closed door, and said

"I'm going to show you just how beautiful you really are." And kissed her.

But little did Sebastian and Rachel know, was that all of the warblers including Skylar who was pleased, saw Sebastian take the female new directions singer through the crowded hallway, up the stair case and to his dorm, as they knew their captain had it bad the petit brunette and is really whipped, smitten and in love with the diva with chocolate brown bambi eyes.