5SOS Preferences and Requests (Part 2)

Perfect (Selena Gomez Version)

I'm sure a lot of you got excited about the title. But it's the Selena Gomez song. Not the 1D one. If you guys want that one, I might write it! Anyways I got this inspiration from the lovely song Perfect by Selena Gomez. It's one of my favorites at the moment so I hope you guys enjoy! xx

Ashton: Curious 'bout the company that you keep
Cause I hear you talking 'bout her in your sleep
And now you've got me talking 'bout her in mine

Lately Ashton has been talking in his sleep and you started to notice a pattern. Every night he'd be talking about a girl that you thought was you, until he said her name. It broke your heart even though you listened to him every time.
Tonight was different though because he started to moan her name. It woke you up and you couldn't take it anymore. You grabbed your pillow and walked down to the couch.

You pulled a blanket over your shivering body and curled up on the soft couch. You closed your eyes and drifted off to sleep. The dream started with her hands roaming over Ashton's shoulders.
"Ashton stay with me." She whispered in his ear, making him lean into her touch. Her eyes enticed him and he wanted more.

While you were dreaming of her, you mumbled her name in your sleep.

The next morning, Ashton woke you up by kissing your cheeks. His soft lips brushing over your skin. Your eyes fluttered open and the image of her disappeared. He smiled down at you and stroked your hair.
"Why did you sleep down here silly goose? It's much warmer up there with me." He spoke sweetly. The thought of him touching her plagued your mind and you moved his hand away from your hair.
"Who is she?" You asked softly, Ashton's expression falling.
"Um. What do you mean?" He tried to act nonchalant. You sat up and hugged your knees to your chest.
"I hear you talking about her in your sleep. And I think I'm talking about her in mine. Who is she?"
"Y/N...I...." You stood up and felt the tears well up.
"Ashton I can't be with someone who isn't honest with me. If you're cheating on me, just tell me. I deserve to know."
He looked defeated and glanced down at his shoes.
"I'm sorry Y/N."
That was all you needed. You ended up walking out the door and out of his life.

Luke: I can feel the distance every time you remember her fingertips
Maybe I should be more like her.

"I remember when she used to run her fingers through my hair and kiss me like I was her world." Luke sniffed and you hugged him close. She had broken up with Luke yesterday because he apparently wasn't good enough for her. He was obviously heartbroken. He loved her. But it hurt you as well because you've loved him for the longest time and you hated to see him so torn.
Every time he talked about her fingertips skimming his skin, you felt the distance between you and the girl Luke wanted. You wanted so badly to be that girl, but it was her.
"Luke I know it hurts. But I promise something better will come along. You deserve someone that will appreciate you for all you are." You spoke, feeling his heart beating against yours. He was so warm and comforting.
"But I miss her. She's the only girl I want. The only girl I've ever loved." He wiped his eyes and stayed close against you. You just hoped he hasn't heard your heart breaking.
"You'll love someone else." You said, fighting tears.
"No I won't. She's the only one that would love me." You knew he was having a hard time, but this was going too far.
"That's not true Lukey." You tried comforting.
"She used to call me Lukey!" He sobbed into your t-shirt, completely oblivious of your feelings.
"Fine. I'll just call you Luke then."
"But she called me that too." You rolled your eyes.
"That's your name idiot." He began to sob harder.
"She used to call me her idiot!"
You moved him away and crossed your arms.
"Alright that's enough. Luke someone will love you because you're you Ok? Every girl you pass seems to be hypnotized by you. Including me. But maybe I should be more like her for you to notice me." You snapped and he looked at you, the sobs ceasing.
"What?"
"What?"
You blushed and looked away from his searching eyes.
"Y/N what did you say?"
You kept your gaze away from him and whispered.
"Maybe I should be more like her."
Luke's hands turned your body to face him. He touched your cheeks and frowned.
"I don't want you to be like her. I want you to be you. You're a great you." He said softly, making you crack a smile.
"Y/N you're my sunshine. Don't forget that Ok? And I do notice you. I love you. Who else will watch HIMYM with me while eating ice cream sundaes of our own creation?" You sighed and took his hands.
"But anyone can do that." You noted and he squeezed your hands.
"Not everyone can make me laugh like you can. Not just anyone can make me smile just by their presence. You can. Y/N you're mine. I want you to be mine. I trust you with my heart, and I hope you trust me with yours."